In our new report ‘Restoring Social Confidence‘ we coin a new concept to understand how people and communities are feeling in the aftermath of the pandemic, and why these feelings matter – Social Confidence. But what do we mean by this term, and how does it link to personal confidence and other terms like ‘trust’ and ‘social cohesion’?
At its core, social confidence is a way to describe our collective societal feelings. As opposed to ‘trust’ which is about how we view others, social confidence is a mix of having faith in other people and institutions, alongside how we feel about our own agency and self-efficacy in society. If personal confidence describes the extent to which an individual trusts their own judgement and abilities, and values oneself, then social confidence is the extent to which we feel we can rely on our community and take shared responsibility within it. It stems from the quality of the relationships between us, our communities, our institutions, and the state, and consequentially, how we process emotions and internalise risk.
Personal confidence has long been considered important within psychological and behavioural theory. The 2018 report from Nesta and Osca, ‘Good Help, Bad Help’, gives a potted history of the term: from 19th century psychologist Frederick Needham’s design of asylums to generate “self-confidence and becoming”, to 20th century psychologist Albert Bandura’s work on ‘self-efficacy’ or the ‘confidence to act’, which argues that “that in order to pursue any goal we must have some confidence that we can achieve that goal”. Self-confidence, however, is something that is seen as something specific to the individual, whereas social confidence speaks to our collective wellbeing.
Social confidence is an outcome of a strong civil society, and is particularly fitting in the context of faith-based social action. The word ‘confidence’ breaks down into con-fidence, or ‘with faith’. Indeed, a recent report by the British Academy and the Faith and Belief Forum suggests that ‘confidence’ is a preferable word to use when describing social cohesion than ‘identity’ or ‘belonging’ because it reflects “an underlying principle of trust” acute in religious communities, but that resonates more widely “as a sense of assuredness that emerges out of harmony between one’s identity, belonging and beliefs”. Compared to other terms which describe the strength of communities, social confidence reflects the importance of shared emotions, values and beliefs in structuring our community lives.
At the moment, social confidence is badly knocked: grief, anxiety, fear, isolation, exhaustion, and boredom (de)animate our collective emotional lives. This was not the case in the early stages of the pandemic when shared purpose unlocked a wave of social action. But since then, many of the gains from the early response have been lost. Research by More in Common found that although a record 62% of people agreed that ‘as society, we look after each other’ in May 2020, this had dropped back down to 26% by early 2021. The erosion of social confidence is concerning because it is when we don’t feel certain or self-assured that we are more easily influenced by misinformation, less able to make informed decisions, and quicker to blame or scapegoat others.
Identifying the core attributes and building blocks of social confidence can help us understand how to restore, strengthen and sustain it in future. There is a lot to be learned from faith-led social action. Faith-based organisations have long been building up social confidence within communities, and interfaith networks broker bonds of shared purpose and agency within and between communities, often in response to potential conflict or social unrest. This work provided solid foundations to build on during the pandemic, enabling a more connected, inclusive and dignified community response.
Our report sets out practical insights from faith-led social action to enable those beyond the faith sector to learn from this work, and shows what support, funding and infrastructure is needed to sustain good practice. Our ‘building blocks for social confidence’ signpost the pathways for other local organisations and services to develop their practice and deepen their impact in the recovery.
First published within the report: Restoring Social Confidence: Lessons from faith-led social action during the COVID-19 pandemic