The UK Government’s £1.57 billion aid package for culture, arts and heritage institutions was extraordinary and hugely welcome news. To give a sense of scale, it is roughly twice the annual budget of Arts Council England. Or only 1.4% of the £111.7 billion annual GVA of the UK’s creative Industries. It is clearly a lot of money; but for a sector that is now so large, also not so much. The question now is where do we go next?
At the front of everyone’s minds, and the funding decisions, is saving what we have got. The funding is a response to the very real risk that existing cultural organisations won’t make it through the present crisis. Clearly, that has to be a major and immediate priority. Things we value must be saved.
But, with a crisis of this scale, not everything is going to survive. Funders will have to continue to make hard choices about what to let go, and organisations will have to look long and hard at their cherished programmes. Are they really going to deliver what audiences need in the years ahead? And are some of the larger, more powerful organisations prepared to demand less in continuing support, so that investment can be spread across the ecosystem?
These tough decisions can be helped by thinking how a time of crisis can also be an opportunity for renewal. Here are our priorities for shaping a new deal for the post-COVID cultural future.
- Redefining community engagement. One positive of the initial COVID-19 crisis has been a refocussing on communities. We have been more connected to the place we live; in touch with family and friends; connecting virtually with communities of interest. And, running alongside the pandemic, Black Lives Matter has brought a global call for justice for communities suffering discrimination. Now is a decisive moment for cultural institutions to shift the dial on their engagement with the communities they serve.
- Reconfiguring the cultural ecosystem. COVID-19 has revealed the vulnerability of cultural supply chains. Many cultural workers are reliant on a few big institutions and vulnerable to even short term down-turns. That insecurity had already excluded talented people from less well-off backgrounds. During the pandemic, it has threatened the whole system. The resilience of the supply chain requires more financial security for artists, freelancers and micro-businesses. That benefits not just individuals but the whole cultural ecosystem, including the big cultural institutions and funders like the Arts Councils.
- Accelerating digital. With no physical audiences, cultural institutions moved quickly to increase and improve their digital offers. The pandemic has driven real innovation. But, when compared to the music, games or television industries, venue-based organisations still have much more scope to ramp up digital engagement. The crisis has supercharged what was already the biggest trend in consumer behaviour and cultural organisations need to keep pushing their digital boundaries.
- Prioritising climate action. The COVID-19 lockdown took the planes out of the sky, let us hear the birds and breathe clean air. The environmental emergency never felt so real. Climate action is the planet’s top priority, and it needs to be culture’s priority too. Buildings and infrastructure need to be sustainable; globe-trotting cultural programming must watch its carbon footprint; artists and cultural leaders should be evangelists for the health of the environment.
With so much in flux, all of these issues are at a point where a push from recovery funding could have a transformative effect.
Paul Owens is Founder and Director of BOP Consulting