There are around 80,000 people in England and Wales living in prisons under restricted regimes due to the pandemic. Some of those people have been locked in their cells for 23 hours a day for several months now, with limited social interaction and without access to support services, family visits or purposeful activities. Moreover, while many arts and cultural organisations have moved swiftly to producing online content and creative activity, this won’t easily reach people in prison, who have extremely limited access to technology.
However, despite the enormity of the crises, we’ve seen arts in criminal justice organisations adapting and innovating, coming up with ways to continue to deliver creative activities for people in prison, even as they themselves fight for survival. What can we learn if we extrapolate out the successful innovations within the criminal justice sector to cultural work in other institutional settings, and with other groups of at-risk people?
Firstly, we must continue to promote the critical value of arts and creativity in combatting isolation and improving wellbeing. We know that arts have the ability to transform people’s lives, including people in the criminal justice system. At the moment, the sector is greatly concerned about the human impact of COVID-19, lockdown and ongoing isolation for people in the criminal justice system, particularly for those who have experienced trauma and/or have pre-existing mental ill-health. While the Ministry of Justice and prison service are now taking steps towards easing restrictions in prisons, as in the community, each prison will have to go at its own pace, and for many it will be a long time before they can return to purposeful activities out of their cells. In such challenging times, ongoing arts and creative activities for people in isolation are an urgent essential.
Second, we need to pay attention to digital exclusion and who think carefully about who doesn’t have easy access to technology. Lockdown in prison means outside organisations that usually deliver in-person support, including creative activities, have reduced access to the prison. In many cases they can’t go in at all. Outside prison, when venues and community spaces closed, the arts and cultural sector moved face-to-face activity online as best it could.
In prisons the National Prison Radio and in-cell television networks have expanded their timetables to drive in-cell learning and creative activity. But not all activities can be adapted for remote delivery, especially for people in prison, most of whom have little or no access to digital technology. The pandemic could be a turning point for the wider cultural sector to re-evaluate inclusion and access in their work, paying closer attention to who is left out by both digital and in-person cultural activities.
Thirdly, let’s learn from the successes of localised, community-based cultural work through lockdown. At the NCJAA, we have seen an enormous demand for in-cell arts activities and resources. Without fanfare, and despite facing huge funding issues and their own uncertain futures, practitioners have been working hard to meet that demand, creating in-cell activities for people isolated in prisons. We’ve heard about plans for collective choral works, visual artworks and poems in prisons, letter writing projects, and group pieces made up of individual contributions created in prison cells. We’ve also seen governors and other prison staff committed to support arts activities, distributing resources door to door in the midst of the crisis.
These initiatives have proved that creativity is an essential part of people’s lives, both for people in the community and those prison, for those who have access to the internet and those who do not. Going forward we have the opportunity to design a cultural ecosystem around individual’s and communities’ cultural needs and priorities, including the needs of people in prison.
It has always been challenging to deliver creative activities in criminal justice settings. It takes commitment and resilience. The COVID-19 crisis has made that challenge even greater. Yet we know that it is still possible to provide people in prison with means to engage in high quality arts and creativity during lockdown, because we are seeing it happen. The demand for arts and culture in criminal justice settings in this time of crisis demonstrates their essential importance across our whole society, and at all times.
Click here to find out more about the NCJAA, and here to read about Clinks’ work during Covid-19, including our work representing the sector to the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, Ministry of Justice, Her Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service and other government bodies.