The Oxford English Dictionary gives three possible meanings for “renew”:
- Resume (an activity) after an interruption. Synonyms: return to, pick up again, take up again, come back to, reopen, begin again, start again, restart, recommence.
- Extend for a further period the validity of (a license, subscription, or contract).
- Replace (something that is broken or worn out). Synonyms: renovate, restore, modernize, redecorate, refurbish, revamp, make over, improve, recondition, rehabilitate, overhaul, redevelop, rebuild, reconstruct, remodel.
The question for the arts and cultural community is whether our definition of “renew” in the context of COVID-19, is simply the first definition or whether we should consider elements of the third definition. My own view is definitely the latter.
When colleagues and I formed the group ‘New Philanthropy for the Arts’ as part of Beacon Collaborative, we were driven by the belief that traditional private philanthropic support for arts and culture is under threat. However, at the same time there are increasingly impressive examples of the beneficial impact that the arts can have on health, education, wellbeing, and the community. This social impact could provide the stimulus for attracting new philanthropy to the sector.
Then came COVID-19 and all mainstream attention has been on how cultural institutions and professionals could survive the financial effects of the pandemic, and when and how in-person activities would return. This current emphasis on survival needs to be balanced alongside an ambitious ‘renewal’ agenda; an agenda that thinks not of resuming activity as it was before, but of replacing and remodelling the cultural sector to deliver true social value.
This is not a matter of choice but necessity: it will be a long time before our old models of economic sustainability will return, particularly for the performing arts. Emergency funds from the state will not continue for ever and additional money is likely to come with strings.
In any case, the events of this year, particularly the pandemic but also the Black Lives Matter movement, will give renewed emphasis to a long-standing points of debate and discussion, including diversity and inclusion (in terms of both artists and audiences), models of artistic excellence, cultural relevance, as well the arts’ beneficial impact on health, education, wellbeing and the community. The challenge for the arts community is to move beyond discussion and statements of intent to sustained action at the core of truly renewed organisations.
What stands in our way is a joined-up consensus on these matters. In my capacity at Beacon Collaborative I have talked to a number of leaders in the sector and whilst many will agree with all the above, most are consumed with economic survival and the practicalities of keeping some sort of show on the road whilst restrictions are in place. The Department for Culture, Media and Sport and Arts Council England also recognise that an agenda for renewal is needed, but with so much still uncertain in the short-term, this work is stalling.
At this time, we need leaders who can work with and through uncertainty. If a regenerative renewal agenda can be forged by the early autumn, philanthropists and sector leaders have a unique opportunity to help shape the ‘strings’ of government funding to attract significant new money into arts and culture. We must seize this opportunity; the alternative, and indeed the default, will just be an appeal to government and private support to keep things afloat and then return to the status quo ante. If we decide to take this well-trodden path, clasping onto the first definition of “renew”, we will inevitably find ourselves with a diminished arts and cultural sector.