The end of July sees the latest series of Love Island come to an end, having captured the interest of 3.4 million people across the UK. Meanwhile, the latest Brexit developments have also come to a head following the launch of the government’s Chequers Plan a few weeks ago – unfortunately the public interest on this front is approximately zero, given that most people have either emigrated to escape the Brexit debates or died of boredom. Nevertheless, there are some common themes.
- It’s hot
Let’s start with an obvious one. Love Island just wouldn’t be the same if it was a bunch of people huddled up around a campsite in the arctic. Just think how many gratuitous shots of bikini thongs or flexing abs we’d miss out on. And of course the Brexit debates are undoubtedly heated – that room at Chequers looked pretty stuffy, not to mention all those political wills and whims flying around. But heated also because Brexit is a big deal. It is the biggest political, economic and political transition in decades. The referendum result was split by 52% and 48%, leaving a ‘divided country’. Although approximately 12% of the electorate have died of boredom since the Brexit negotiations began (please note this is fake news. But see here for some ideas on how to make the public debate on Brexit less boring) that still leaves a fair few million of us who didn’t vote to leave the EU, and some who did but don’t support a ‘hard Brexit’ that cuts off economic and political ties with our continental neighbours. It’s a tricky, sweaty, situation for a government tasked with negotiating the future relationship with the EU, not helped when various campaigning factions fan the flames by insisting that their interpretation of the referendum result is the only way forward. The only way to cool down the debate is to go beyond the shouting, and have an open public consultation process on the proposed direction of travel so that it’s not just those shouting the loudest who are heard.
2. Tribes, tests and teamwork
The most frequent question from someone who hasn’t watched Love Island: What’s the point? Are these sexy 20-somethings put into a glamorous villa solely to flirt and fornicate on live TV in order to win the cash? Having tuned into the programme for the last few weeks, I was surprised to learn it’s a bit more nuanced than that. In order to survive on the island, the couples need to demonstrate that they are committed to each other and are prepared to work as a team. Naturally there’s some good ol’ organised fun to help them do so: such as the blindfolded bake-off, ‘horseracing’ on space-hoppers, or parenting plastic babies for the day. Challenges are set to gauge the couples’ compatibility or their verdicts on the relationship dynamics of their peers. But the idea isn’t that the most passionate, sexually-charged couple wins – it’s often more pragmatic than romantic. In the early stages of the series, awkward Dr Alex and Samira survived as a ‘friendship couple’ because they were honest about their platonic feelings for each other, but hopeful they would have a chance for love if they stayed. Their friendships with the other individuals, rather than their romantic potential, helped their chances of survival. The same pragmatism applies to Brexit: the ultimate test of teamwork. Beyond the factions which exist to proclaim that “Brexit means Brexit” or fight to the end to “Stop Brexit”, most people understand that we all have to live together, on this small island we call Britain. A mix of forced companionship and proximity means Brexit must result in something which not everyone will be happy with, but most people can live with.
3. There’s A LOT of personalities
Ah yes, the winning formula for reality TV. Get to know the individuals, their hopes and dreams, their dramatic back-story. Find their weak spots, and then engineer a situation where they need to prove themselves by overcoming their fears. Which is exactly how the media have portrayed the Brexit discussions. Not a day has gone by in the last two years without Brexit making the headlines – but the news stories continue to cover power battles amongst politicians, rather than factual information and analysis of the negotiations and how this might affect our everyday lives. We haven’t learned one of the most valuable lessons from the referendum campaigns, that a focus on personality politics forces people to make emotive, rather than rational decisions (analysis of the media headlines in the run-up to the 2016 referendum found that David Cameron’s name was mentioned more that the issues of jobs, healthcare, housing, pay and human rights combined.) The effects of an inaccessible, intangible debate are particularly off-putting for millennials who in all other walks of life can find easily accessible and relevant information (and yes, “what sorts of stationery does Jack from Love Island sell” does count as relevant). Although Brexit fatigue is common amongst people of all ages – even those who would usually take an interest in current affairs – millennials in particular care most about the economic effects of Brexit on jobs and living circumstances. We desperately need the media to focus on practical implications instead of personality politics.
4. Mass dumping, and new arrivals
Over the last eight weeks, Love Island has had a revolving door of spangly new hotties who enter the villa at random intervals, upsetting the status quo and turning the heads of previously committed lovers. Same goes for our politicians on Brexit, minus the spangly hottie bit. The government’s Chequers Plan was a notable compromise between the calls from the ‘hard Brexiteers’ who want to remove the UK from the single market and the customs union, and from others who want to have a continued trading relationship with the EU and abide by its rules in order to do so. Following the publication of the government’s proposed approach to negotiations at the start of July, various politicians resigned from their postings (within the government or the Conservative party, not as MPs) including Brexit Secretary David Davis and Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson. Why pull their own ejector seat cords? The principle of ‘Cabinet collective responsibility’ means that members of the Cabinet are (theoretically) constrained from speaking out against something which they were all supposed to have agreed on at the Chequers meeting. So now they can be all shouty again from the sidelines (just like Love Islanders automatically become showbiz pundits the minute they’re out).
5. There’s voting… but it’s unclear what will happen next
Islanders reach their expiry date on the show when they are voted off, individually or in couples, usually by a public vote. But the terms of the vote evolves too… sometimes it determines the most popular contestants, who are then safe from a further elimination process – other times the most unpopular couples are booted out straight away. Certainly keeps the public on our toes. The 2016 referendum was similarly vague, giving voters two choices: to leave the European Union, or remain as members of the EU. No one voted for the type of Brexit or the terms of the UK’s future relationship with the EU – so this ambiguity has inevitably led to endless squabbling about the legitimate course of action. Many people of all political persuasions have criticised the way in which the referendum was constructed and the uncertainty that has ensued over the legitimate process in which to exit the EU, not to mention the definition of the ‘will of the people’ in voting to leave and whether the official campaigns would be held accountable for their promises. It is clear that some of the major points of contention that have arisen since the referendum could have been avoided by a more thorough process in advance. If there is a second referendum held on the final deal with the EU, it would need to be structured around a formal public education process and have a lead-time that allows for deliberative dialogue rather than heated debate. In the meantime, there are still opportunities for more widespread consultation processes with younger people and the electorate more generally, as a first start to rebuilding trust in Brexit decisions and politics as a whole.
6. The lingo!!
One of the hallmarks on Love Island is the turns of phrase used by contestants. Here’s a quick dummy’s guide: grafting means working hard to impress someone, cracking on is all about proceeding with a love interest, and getting mugged off is being taken for a fool or feeling undervalued by others. Brexit needs just as much translation. In case you missed it, the term single market refers to a group of countries (EU members and a few others) who agree to allow free movement, goods, services and capital between them (i.e. no checks or restrictions), while customs union is an arrangement between countries who do not charge tariffs on imports or exports with each other. The European Economic Area (EEA) is a group of countries who aren’t members of the EU but participate in the single market and follow its rules. The European Free Trade Association (EFTA) is a free trade area which means that all non-agricultural goods can move between participating countries without tariffs or restrictions. Confused? Basically the distinction is the ease in which businesses can trade across borders, and the extent by which the sellers/ buyers of those goods need to abide by certain rules and standards. You’re welcome.
7. Villa life, international lifestyle
Let’s just think about the Love Island setup for a second. They’re in a villa, a pretty fancy one, in Majorca. There’s a verrrrrry nice infinity pool and it’s almost always sunny to the point where the contestants have all developed that typical Brits-abroad deep orange tan. They also seem to have an endless supply of wine and other goodies (although we never see them snacking). Could all this happen after Brexit? Well, who knows? The Chequers Plan proposes to allow mutual short-term travel and work opportunities for UK citizens in the EU and vice versa, and lays out a proposal for free trade in goods with the EU (so the wine might be ok) but restrictions on services (so the production teams might have a few issues). It’s impossible to be able to predict the actual logistics at this stage. The Love Islanders might not know what Brexit is (there was a painful conversation where Scouse model Hayley thought that Brexit would mean cutting down trees) but, if they are typical of other millennials, they expect and value international opportunities, are positive about the effects of globalisation on their own lives, and support collaboration with other countries, even if this means a ‘trade off’ with national sovereignty. Love Island in Brighton just wouldn’t be as fun.
8. Strong and stable wins the race
Consistent favourites to win since the earliest episodes of the show, the most popular couple is undoubtedly Jack and Dani, a stationery salesman from Kent and the daughter of actor Danny Dyer respectively who were matched on day one and have stayed loyal to each other ever since. Unaffected by sexy new arrivals or lie detector challenges, they’ve talked about moving in together, baby names, their schedule for this Christmas’s family festivities and have managed to stay likeable whilst doing so. They’re strong, and they’re stable. But that’s because they went through the journey together, and shaped their own terms for their relationship. The ‘strong and stable’ Brexit which was once championed by the Prime Minister didn’t do that – it was a vision imposed top-down by a particular political faction. For Love Island, it’s the end of the game; for Brexit, it’s not. There’s still time to build a truly strong and stable Brexit based on a formal public consultation process: a listening opportunity not a PR exercise. Following the publication of the Chequers Plan and the resignations of the most uncompromising politicians, and with just months to go until the terms of the UK/ EU deal are put to the European Parliament and the UK Parliament, now would be a good time to start.
9. It’s not over until it’s over (or is it?)
This series of Love Island has been the longest to date, running for eight weeks. And ITV bosses revealed that they hope the show continue for another FIVE YEARS. That’s a lot more bikinis. Meanwhile, the process of leaving the EU will take the best part of a decade to implement, with the terms of our future relationship yet to be agreed. And on leaving the EU, the UK Parliament may have the power to amend laws on migration, human rights, the environment and other areas which until now have been agreed in partnership with other European countries. The Brexit debate will go on and on for years to come. With this challenge of uncertainty comes opportunities – opportunities for political leaders to find solutions that achieve compromise and rebuild public trust, opportunities for consultative dialogue that helps people understand the Brexit process and feed into the decisions that are made, and opportunities to shape a Brexit that stands the test of time for future generations by re-engaging people in the political process. But if we don’t start changing the terms of the conversation, we’ll also have to live with the consequences of a divided country, embittered politics, and citizens who feel disempowered… or simply mugged off.
Caroline Macfarland is the co-author of a new Common Vision report, A Generation Together? What do millennials want from Brexit?