It is widely cited that young people within Britain voted overwhelmingly in favour of Remain during the EU referendum. 66.4% of 18-35s voted Remain a greater proportion than any other age group. But now that Brexit is a certainty, what do young people want from the negotiations?
A recent report from the APPG on a Better Brexit for Young People found that that 59% of 18-24s are dissatisfied with how the government has acted since the Brexit vote, and feel poorly represented in negotiations. Having conducted 40 focus groups of various geographical and socio-economic backgrounds, the report indicated that consensus exists within the youth demographic and that young people collectively prioritise retaining EU membership opportunities and rights, alongside economic growth and jobs. Young people were found to support a tolerant multicultural Britain post-Brexit, and displayed concern towards the anti-immigration message of EU withdrawal. This reflects Common Vision’s 2016 report, A Generation Apart, which analysed the drivers behind voting behaviours, found that young people are less concerned by issues of national sovereignty and immigration than older people, and instead prioritise the economy, jobs and public services.
So on the face of it, British young people collectively want a Brexit that produces economic growth, protects EU membership rights, and safeguards tolerance.
On the other hand however, another recent report from the Intergenerational Foundation argued that 18-35s cannot be treated as a single unit when considering Brexit, but instead should be seen as a broad-church of diverse opinions and demands. The study identified four groups, which each voted in the referendum due to different concerns:
- Eurosceptics: This accounts for a minority of young voters who voted Leave based on concerns of immigration and in defence of a British identity. 87% want immigration to be reduced.
- Affluent Pro Europeans: This group voted Remain due to concerns towards the economic risks of Brexit. They earn high incomes, with a third earning £60,000 or more, and enjoy the benefits of travel as 75% had visited other European states.
- Celtic Pro-Europeans: Those that live in the devolved areas of Wales and Scotland that voted Remain based on concerns that Brexit would strengthen the Westminster government. 70% supported pro-independence parties such as Plaid Cymru and the SNP in the 2015 General Election, and show discontent towards the current state of British politics. 62% want increased immigration.
- Left-Wing Pro-Europeans: Those that support European integration and favour social and environmental justice. 50% perceive themselves to be at a high risk of poverty, while 35% earn less than £25,000 a year. 66% support increased immigration.
These findings therefore would indicate that although there is some consensus between different groups of British young people, it would be naïve to paint all young voters with the same Brexit brush. It is clear that the majority of young voters share a concern about the economic risks of Brexit, and show disaffection towards the anti-immigration messages of some ‘hard’ Brexiteers. However, while Remainers were united around a common goal of opposing Brexit, they are now vying for different political and economic demands such as increased devolution or increased economic redistribution. Likewise, younger demographics should not be categorised as one, but should instead be seen as collection of groups that share similar goals – sometimes based on competing motivations.
Taking all of this into account in the context of negotiations, it is clear that Theresa May and her team will not be able to produce a Brexit that satisfies an entire generation of young people. However, to appease the majority it is clear that she must produce a ‘soft’ Brexit that minimises the impact on the economy and citizenship rights to fulfil young Brits’ principle demands. Despite underlying differences, young people want a Brexit that maximises future opportunities, and this must be produced to limit further political disengagement.