As a Northerner stranded in London for many years against my better judgement, I often think about how little policy focus there is on regions. It’s the same with Brexit as it is with other government policies. While much attention has been given to the impact of Brexit on national economy and policy, less has been paid the the effect that it will have on Britain’s individual regions. Research shows that young people frequently demonstrate more interest in local and community issues than national politics, so it’s up to us as millennials to raise this issue of how Brexit will affect our communities. Three policy issues spring to mind when thinking about Brexit and regionalism.
First, how will Brexit affect the UK’s Industrial Strategy? The strategy proposes “to ensure that every place meets its potential by working”. Many civil society organisations have called for more balanced growth across the country. However, there has been little analysis of how Brexit proposals may affect specific places and retain and reinvest wealth at sub-regional level, so that resilient places can provide jobs and skills in line with the needs and expectations of the generation entering the workforce.
The Government published its Trade Bill on 7th November, a key piece of Brexit legislation. The bill is focuses on ensuring continuity by giving a basis in UK law for trade policy aspects currently based in EU legislation. While the leave campaign argued that exiting the EU would ultimately benefit Britain, we are already hearing reports of leave-voting towns seeking exceptions to ensure that local trade isn’t damaged. Grimsby overwhelmingly voted to leave the EU in last year’s referendum, with leave taking 70 per cent of the vote. Yet this week Grimsby industry spokespeople called on MPs to offer special free trade status to the port town to ensure its seafood industry isn’t hit by Brexit. If solid leave towns are calling for a regionalised approach to trade post-Brexit, it’s worth the government taking a look at how this could happen.
A third issue is the discussion of the potential to regionalise immigration policies post-Brexit. Regionalised visas could facilitate the flexibility to meet local skills shortages while making immigration policy more responsive to local opinion. Yet regional migration policies would be difficult to enforce and could potentially create a ‘back door’ into the country from regions with more liberal immigration policies. The Migration Observatory has published a useful report which asks whether different parts of the UK should have different immigration policies, summarising the arguments in favour of and against regional visas. One effect of regional migration policies, for example, is that is would bring decision-making on migration closer to the communities affected. The advantages of would be that local accountability might create a feeling of control over migration, with local interest groups more involved in policy debate. On the flip side, the majority of UK migration would remain outside of the region’s control.
The other key disadvantage here is that the political institutions required for this to work, in particular elected regional governments, do not exist across all of the UK. Indeed the main international examples of a regional approach to migration policy, Australia and Canada, have federal structures with democratically elected legislatures. Perhaps Brexit is the push we need for stronger regional devolution. This would be an exciting and positive development from Brexit, and could be the real way we take back control into our communities.