Unexpectedly, intergenerational fairness emerged front and centre of the election campaign. This should be a welcome development for us millennials, and we should set down our avocado brioche and fidget spinners and pay attention.
For decades, both major parties have produced public policy specifically targeted towards older generations, which has resulted in young people being institutionally under-represented. There are no prizes for guessing why. Older people vote, and vote in powerful numbers. Far fewer young people perform this civic duty, and we don’t consistently back any one party, like our parents and grandparents often do. The result is a policy agenda which overlooks young people.
The thumping lead which pollsters gave to the Conservatives was clearly a factor in the Prime Minister’s decision to call a snap election. It’s now apparent that she also saw this as an opportunity to press the reset button on some such policies. One such example is the Winter Fuel Allowance, which many Westminster types view as a thinly veiled bribe, a simple cash payment to pensioners which symbolises the Government’s allegiance to the elderly. Theresa May proposed means-testing this payment, which would remove the benefit from pensioners earning £45k or more. Some wealthy pensioners – Labour Peer Alan Sugar is one – have tried and failed to return this money to the state before, on the grounds that there are more urgent and deserving recipients than millionaires and celebrities.
Another reform that was proposed in the Conservative manifesto was amending the Triple Lock on pensions, which has ensured that the State pension increases annually by at least 2.5%. Once again, it’s hard to consider this as anything other than a cash-for-votes policy, especially given the devastating effects of austerity on public services elsewhere. These proposed reforms should have been welcomed as efforts to close the generational divide.
The most high profile example, however, was the reform to social care funding, now better known as the Dementia Tax. A policy to unlock property equity to help pay for social care was quickly watered down into a consultation, then a ‘principle’, following outrage from opposition and media groups. Many criticisms of the policy were valid, especially that elderly people would be unfairly punished for developing illnesses which aren’t covered by the NHS. However it did spark a debate about who should shoulder the cost of an ageing population, correctly pointing out that ploughing more money into the current system does not tackle structural issues.
The sum total of these debates is that the Conservatives effectively became the party proposing reforms to improve intergenerational fairness, while Labour promised they will protect the finances of the elderly. Given the outcome of the election, where younger voters seemingly flocked to boost Labour’s numbers, this might seem bizarre.
In conversation about these issues, a common reaction from older voters is to become incensed, and remind the snowflake generation that pensioners have worked hard and contributed their entire lives, that they deserve a comfortable retirement. This is unquestionably true. However young voters do not want an unfair advantage, nor even a head start, but only a level playing field. They want the chance to work and contribute, to one day enjoy a similar retirement. With this objective, current public policy is not fit for purpose.
This is why we can take heart from the election having shown that low turnout from young people at elections is a reversible trend. We now need to roll our sleeves up beyond voting, get stuck into debates about intergenerational fairness, and make a great deal of noise about the issues that matter to us.