Further to the publication of our report, Follow the money: Is the time right for (more) tax hypothecation in September, Common Vision hosted an event in Parliament last week to bring together leading tax experts to discuss the limitations, benefits and debates around tax hypothecation.
We were joined by Helen Miller, Associate Director for the Institute for Fiscal Studies; Paul Morton, Office for Tax Simplification; Stella Amiss, Head of Tax Policy at PwC UK; and Kirsty Blackman MP, the SNP’s Deputy Westminster Leader and Spokesperson on the Economy. The panel was chaired by Common Vision’s director Caroline Macfarland.
Caroline opened the discussion with an overview of our recent report. She commented on the importance of definitions: hypothecation can mean many things, from ‘strong’ hypothecation, where a tax revenue wholly covers the cost of a public service or benefit ‘weak’ hypothecation, where the service may be funded through other additional revenues. “Wide” hypothecation refers to funding a broad public service, whereas the ‘narrow’ form focuses on a specific policy. Finally, ‘presentational’ hypothecation describes a situation where the proceeds of a tax are communicated as paying for a specific service, but this is not demonstrated or evidenced on a technical level.
Firmly against the concept of tax hypothecation, Helen Miller argued that the best case for hypothecation – that it establishes a clear link with what is being taxed and what is being spent – is also what makes it impractical in reality. Strong hypothecation would mean important public services would be vulnerable to lower tax revenues in recessions, or circumstances where the tax base is subject to change over time due to factors such as automation and an ageing population. Whereas weak hypothecation (where revenue also comes from elsewhere) would mean there is no meaningful reason for the hypothecated tax in the first place. Helen’s key point was that hypothecation detracts from the larger debate regarding how we raise money and how we spend money.
Stella Amiss agreed with much of Helen’s critique, but pointed out that hypothecation could be used to target an immediate short-term need, using a sunset clause for example to ensure that the purpose of the tax was not diluted. Hypothecated taxes could also be used to increase general accountability between politicians and citizens, and bring tax onto the agenda between the five-year electoral cycle. The concept of establishing a clear mental link between paying taxes and receiving government services could potentially lead to greater public interest in tax policy.
Paul Morton’s comments picked up on the theme of public understanding of, and interest in, the tax system – noting the limited knowledge that many people have around what percentage of public funds are actually spend on specific public services. This lack of knowledge, even amongst the ‘well-informed’, limits public engagement with the tax system in a meaningful way.
Kirsty Blackman MP agreed that even many MPs know little about the relationship between taxation and spending, with a parliamentary process that often means decision makers are not equipped to comprehensively deliberate these issues adequately. Kirsty noted that the issue of trust plays a role in public engagement – a strong form of hypothecation may not mean that people believe that the proceeds of a tax end up where it is promised. Kirsty also made the point that political decisions are also influenced by who votes, so any move towards greater hypothecation must include an awareness that it could entrench economic disadvantage amongst segments of the population who are less likely to vote.
The panellists agreed that hypothecation has a number of weaknesses. In its pure form it could be burdened with practical issues that derive from its structure and purpose. On the other hand, hypothecation has promise to unlock political dialogue and public participation with the tax system. It could be one solution to short-term funding gaps and address swings in tax apathy by establishing clear links between money paid in taxes and services received. But as emphasised in Common Vision’s own report, there is a risk of using hypothecated taxes as a ‘proxy’ to address challenges such as public trust and taxpayer education which could be solved via other means. It is important to recognise the first principles, and key objectives, of a responsible tax system before instigating other solutions.