It is no secret that the current UK government is facing huge challenges and amongst these is the sustainability of public finances. The rise of social media enables the public to respond to tax increases with unprecedented immediacy leading to media storms and inevitably, reversals of policies, such as the often maligned ‘mansion’ and ‘dementia’ taxes.
Hypothecation – the earmarking certain taxes for specific services –is not a new idea and has been used with some success in countries such as Germany and Japan. Before evaluating the merits of possible hypothecation of the NHS in the UK we must first ensure the social contract between taxpayers and the government is stable enough ensure long term engagement.
Public perception of tax rises is clearly important, but we must be aware when the government is in control of the narrative. When speaking about hypothecation, Nick Macpherson – who acted as permanent secretary to the Treasury until 2016 – stated that whilst he was against hypothecation, it allows the government to ‘use some smoke and mirrors to get people to agree to a tax increase’. It is clear then that some MPs feel hypothecation makes tax rises more palatable. However, it is damaging to public trust if they then buy into a policy which has been deliberately misrepresented.
Given the UK’s current political climate, the government need to be cautious in how they frame tax increases. Governments have historically had success in raising ‘stealth taxes’, taxes of which the taxpayer has little awareness. An obvious example of this is ‘invisible NICs’. While the share of government revenue from Income Tax has remained fairly stable over the last few decades, the revenue generated from NICs has risen over the last few decades.
NIC rates too have continued this upward trend (from 5.5% in 1975 to currently 12%). However, public awareness of NICs seems to remain low. Most taxpayers know the basic rate of tax is 20% but few understand that in reality the basic rate is more like 30% once NICs are factored in. As a report from the ICEAW states ‘This difference in perception has allowed successive governments to use NIC as a mechanism for raising overall revenues by stealth’. Chancellors therefore take advantage of this by cutting obvious taxes that people can recognise and increasing the ones that people pay less attention to.
‘Stealth taxes’ by their nature result in higher taxpayer compliance which alone is not a negative. It does however bring about problems when polls are being used to test the appetite for higher taxes. How can we ethically ask taxpayers if they agree to higher taxes if they do not fully understand the current level of taxes being paid?
How the public is asked to consider a new policy when it is put forth by a government is important. For fair representation of tax rises it is essential that taxpayers understand what the proposal is for and what other options are available. Whilst It benefits the government to present hypothecation as the ‘right thing’ it is not fair to present it as the only thing that can be done to save the NHS. Of course, if you ask people if they would be willing to contribute slightly more to the NHS to provide better healthcare and higher wages for nurses the answer from the majority would most certainly be ‘yes’.
As such, the framing of the polling questions are deliberately biased. Asking the right questions provides a better gauge of public support, increases transparency and opens up a fairer discussion between taxpayers and the government. The YouGov Polling the question ‘Would you support or oppose increasing the basic rate of income tax from 20% to 21% and using the money raised to increase spending on the NHS?’ is not a fair question. If instead the question was ‘Would you support the government reducing tax cuts on the wealthy or would you prefer to increase the tax you pay?’ I would speculate the public support for hypothecation would somewhat diminish.
The current proposed hypothecation of the NHS plays on people’s desire to ‘do good’ and enable the government to increases taxes without any transparency or strengthened social contract. It leaves me questioning whether the government’s goal of hypothecated taxes is to raise funding for the NHS or is it ‘smoke and mirrors’ to get the public to agree to higher taxes.