A few years ago there was a provincial tax in a large country not far from Europe called “the tax in support of the local football team”. It may be that this was a particularly popular way of raising more revenue although those who were not soccer enthusiasts might have been less impressed. This is, perhaps, an extreme example of a hypothecated tax, dedicated to a particular cause but, in principle, why would an “NHS tax” be any different?
However, before addressing this question, there is a need for greater insights into current public understanding of how taxes are raised and spent – even among highly informed and politically connected individuals as well as other taxpayers and citizens. How many people know that total taxes raised in the UK equate to around £10,000 per head? Or that spending on health is around £2000 per head or 20% of the total? Armed with these facts would a member of the public say that we should spend more in total, or more on health or just more out of the same total collected on health? Perception is as important as anything else in this context.
An important precursor to acting on hypothecation will be to ensure that people can recognise and understand what the tax system, or individual taxes, exist to do. In the public eye, fairness has become a central requirement of the tax system although there is of course no single sense of what is fair. In this context it is unfortunate that many comments and studies on hypothecation are not quite as balanced as they might be. But this report from Common Vision’s Responsible Tax Lab presents the issues in a very objective way and for that reason is particularly persuasive. The arguments for and against are explored methodically and hypothecation is presented not as a silver bullet but as a tool to be deployed intelligently by tax policymakers as one possible element of a well-designed tax system.
First published in the Foreword to Follow the money: Is the time right for (more) tax hypothecation?