The Responsible Tax Lab’s recent work on tax hypothecation has raised some very important questions about public awareness of how much tax is raised and how it is spent. For example, many people might take the view that more should be spent on the NHS and on health in general, but few would be able to recall how much of all public expenditure is currently spent on health – the answer is more than 20% according to the latest summary published in February. Health, welfare and pensions amount to nearly 60% of all public expenditure. Then there is education and a host of other functions to be funded. Does this change the picture? How much, as a proportion of the total, feels the ‘right’ amount to be spent on health?
Many taxpayers receive an Annual Tax Summary which includes a pie chart showing how government revenues are spent yet some taxpayers either have little recall of this summary or find that it is not so easy to understand. Although this information is publicly available in great detail, the Annual Tax Summary is a very convenient and useful means to raise awareness of how tax revenues are spent, and it seems important that taxpayers receive it and that it can be readily understood. Perhaps more research is needed as to why some readers find the summary hard to follow and whether a different presentation might be more effective.
It is not surprising that the public finances are complex and the mechanism by which particular government functions are funded is not straightforward. However, until there is a slightly greater awareness of the broad picture there is a question as to whether hypothecation can be meaningfully discussed. Would it be worthwhile to replace one funding mechanism which is not understood by a different mechanism which would perhaps also not be understood! Or is it the case that by its nature this kind of process is too intricate and complicated to be easily communicated in a form in which the majority of taxpayers would be willing to invest sufficient time to understand?
This debate raises some even broader questions about the tax system. It seems possible, with the application of technology, that much of the complexity of the tax system could be ‘papered over’ with technology so that a simple user interface or user experience might rest on top of a hugely complex underlying system. Is this acceptable for the vast majority of taxpayers? Most people might be quite content with this. Or should every taxpayer be able to receive a full explanation of the detail standing behind their final tax position and the law and practice applied in reaching that position?
Finally, there is an interesting question as to how much a typical taxpayer should be expected to engage with the tax system. If an individual has relatively simple tax affairs as an employee, they will not have to submit a return and their tax affairs will effectively be taken care of by their employer on their behalf. Where, however, does this individual’s responsibility begin and end? Should we require every citizen to confirm their tax position every year? Is it important that every individual knows how much they have contributed? Even if we provide everyone with their summary and they read, understand and can recall their contribution, we would still only have addressed their income tax liability. Some people will contribute more in VAT than in income tax and there is currently no practical means of calculating an individual’s VAT contribution. How meaningful can an individual’s income tax summary be in isolation?
A whole range of questions are raised by examining hypothecation as a concept, all of which perhaps require some thought before we can address the practicalities of hypothecation itself.