Hypothecation might simply mean that the Treasury raises a particular tax, promises to spend it on a particular thing, and at the outset does exactly that. However, the following year, the amounts of money raised from one and spent on the other may have got out of kilter, for all kinds of legitimate reasons, and decisions might then be made once again about each as parts of the general pot.
If hypothecation is to have a harder, more enduring meaning, it seems that control over the money raised must be passed to someone else – someone other than the Treasury, which inevitably looks to balance all the elements of tax and spending against each other. Tolls are paid to bridge or road construction companies, for example, and health taxes could be paid to medical or insurance organisations. Of course, there is still a real issue around what happens if the revenue stream is more buoyant or less buoyant than expected in relation to the financial cost of the spending commitment. But, leaving that to one side, are there any parallels from our experience that we can draw on?
Perhaps one parallel is with devolution. Scottish taxes, for example, are outside the Treasury’s control. True, they are not hypothecated to one thing, but they are earmarked for whatever the Scottish Parliament decides, and there is more to spend on those things, or less, as those taxes are more buoyant, or less.
One issue that needs thinking about is the scope and coherence of the tax powers and spending areas devolved, or hypothecated. For example, a high-earning business owner in Scotland will currently be facing a top rate of income tax of 46%, up from the 45% that still applies elsewhere in the UK. There has been some talk about whether this – particularly if it turns out to be the start of a trend – could lead such people to move south. But if the business owner stays put and incorporates the business, they would no longer pay Scottish income tax. Instead, they would fall into the scope of corporation and dividend tax, which generally produce a lower tax burden and, crucially, are UK rather than devolved taxes.
The issue here is not whether a particular level of tax devolution, as with hypothecation, is right or wrong. It is about the coherence, or lack of it, in the definition of the scope of such devolution. It is about exactly where you draw the line between the devolved or hypothecated tax and spending areas that you have given over to the new authority and the other taxes and powers that you keep with the Treasury.
One big issue with healthcare is its relationship with the wider care of elderly and other groups of people who do not need, at least not constantly, medical intervention of the type provided by the NHS. Instead, they might need some help, have regular medical prescriptions or even be cared for more completely in their own home or in a care home. Is a hypothecated health tax also going to cover this type of care, and if not, where is the line to be drawn? And how do we deal with people who by staying, or not staying, an extra day or two in hospital, move resources in or out of the hypothecated spending programme?
Of course, this issue currently lies between NHS and local authority budgets, but however generous a hypothecated tax fund for healthcare might become, it would remain a difficult issue unless great care was taken over the definition of the scope of the hypothecation in question.