Hypothecated tax – the pre-allocation of a tax for a given cause – is everywhere at the moment. But in discussions of how impractical it is in technical terms, one major factor driving its appeal as a political tool seems to have been overlooked. This is the emotional space it creates, allowing the taxpayer to feel a sense of ownership – and benevolence – over their contribution to the common good. In a political era increasingly characterised by secrecy and exclusivity, experiments in hypothecation might offer some insight into the psychological readiness of the polis for more active citizenship.
Research has highlighted that people who (mistakenly) believe their national insurance directly funds the NHS are happy for it to do so – and would contribute more if they knew it funded that. For me, this suggests that contrary to the overly popularised narrative that people are self-interested, when people are given the chance to feel a sense of agency around their role in collective social security, they are more than willing to so. Perhaps what those of us in government need to be asking ourselves about tax is how to better enable the joy of giving.
The question of public appetite becomes more interesting when comparisons are drawn to what the state most needs to invest in, and the political moments in which hypothecation tends to gain popularity. There is plenty of evidence to suggest that local public services need to shift from focusing on crisis to focusing on prevention. However, if it’s true that hypothecation tends to gain popularity after periods of austerity (in which public opinion about spending is under greatest scrutiny) these moments are also characterised by a paucity of state investment in prevention: The first thing to go when resources are scarce. Subsequently, this underinvestment leads to an increase in demand – generating a crisis. We have to some extent seen this cycle play out, and generate buy-in to a hypothecated tax, in the recent and widespread public acceptance of the social care precept.
Another benefit of hypothecation is, arguably, greater accountability. However, I would say that there is not necessarily a direct and natural connection between the two. The broad categories for which hypothecated taxes can be allocated mean there will always be multiple actors making decisions about spend. For instance, the main focal point of debate on hypothecation right now relates to health and social care. Yes, there has been a growth in policy infrastructure to enable this – health and wellbeing boards (HWBs) bring together local networks of change makers and integrators, while sustainability and transformation plans (STPs) aim to build vision and perspective. But, research suggests that these structures lack accountability, and simultaneously often fail to deliver prevention. This is largely due to power imbalances between actors involved in governance.
This might sound pessimistic, but all is not lost. I recently came across an excellent example of a hypothecated tax being used to strengthen the voice of civil society in economic change; transform structures of accountability; and deliver intelligent, preventative infrastructure to address one of the greatest challenges we face – automation and what this means for the security of labour. The exemplar is Sweden’s ‘wage-earner funds’, the idea for which arose in the mid-1970s, when Sweden’s powerful confederation of blue-collar unions endorsed a proposal for two direct, hypothecated taxes – one of 20% on pre-tax profits exceeding one million SEK (c. US$115,000 at the present exchange rate) or 6% of a firm’s total payroll costs, whichever was higher (accounting for inflation and other appropriations). The second was a 0.2% tax of total payroll costs of all corporations, private and public. These would go into wage-earner funds (WEFs), allowing a gradual transfer of ownership from private individuals and institutions to collective entities, governed by union-appointed directors, providing more direct employee representation at shareholder meetings via stock holdings.
WEFs were abolished by a centre-right coalition which took office in 1991 – a reminder that without a constitution, there is no more chance of protecting interventions funded by a hypothecated tax than there would be under general taxation. But lessons nevertheless remain. With enough political imagination it is possible to use hypothecated taxes to create infrastructure which can pre-emptively resist crises, empower civil society in relation to the state, and rework the infrastructures of accountability in our economic systems.