How can communications transform the way that taxpayers perceive tax? What role can design and data play in promoting or provoking sentiments towards taxation? How could alternative ways of presenting tax information change the way that people feel about the tax system? These were some of the questions considered at a recent workshop hosted by Sheffield Political Economy Research Institute (SPERI) and University of the Arts London, as part of an ESRC-funded collaborative project.
The aim of the workshop was to bring together a number of tax specialists (mainly academics and campaigners) with information designers to review and co-produce a series of alternatives to HMRC’s Annual Tax Summary.
Introduced in 2014, the Annual Tax Summary is a document sent to taxpayers that explains how their income tax has contributed to public spending. It is apparently received by millions of people in the UK, although no-one at the workshop seemed to know who exactly currently receives these summaries and who doesn’t. (If you can solve the mystery, please leave a comment below!)
Although it seeks to boost transparency, HMRC’s summary document may in fact be decreasing taxpayers’ motivation and willingness to pay tax, according to previous research from the University of Sheffield. Researchers conducted a survey where respondents were split into four groups and each received a different format of the tax summary – the government’s official format, an alternative format designed by the Institute for Fiscal Studies and another alternative proposed by the tax campaigner, Richard Murphy. The fourth group was not shown a tax summary. The survey then asked questions about attitudes to tax and public spending, finding that the ways in which categories of state spending were described affected the individual’s support for public spending. These findings echoed previous criticism of the government’s ‘creative accounting’ methods in choosing to categorise certain spending into particular ‘buckets’, and the language which it uses to describe these categories, both of which might provoke particular attitudes or bias towards the public purse (e.g. support for austerity measures, or less sympathy with welfare claimants).
If the way in which tax information is presented and communicated can potentially provoke negative responses, can design and communication also be used to inspire positive sentiment about taxation? This is the essay question for the research and design teams.
The motivation for the project is an important one. “Tax is the lifeblood of public life. It funds public services and contributes to the formation of citizen identities and solidarities. While public opinion continues to support the payment of taxes, this generally positive tax morale is threatened by an economic narrative which holds that tax is a burden. There is therefore vital work to be done to understand how key social actors and institutions can promote positive attitudes towards taxation and champion the role of tax in society.”
Participants were asked to explore ideas for potential alternative tax statements using ‘design thinking’ methods – an approach that is becoming more popular in public policy making, and used by the Cabinet Office’s Policy Lab as well as other international examples such as Denmark’s MindLab. Design-led methods tend to think about service design based on the user experience or ‘journey’, rather than with the policy objective as the starter point, building behavioural analysis and creative engagement techniques into the design of solutions.
Part two in this blog series will reflect on some of the deliberations and ideas for a different type of tax summary. In the meantime, we will leave you with some of the questions we were prompted to reflect on. Plus a snapshot of the creative tools and techniques used during the discussion!
- What is the current ‘story’ depicted by HMRC’s Annual Tax Summary? Who is the ‘protagonist’? Who are the other ‘characters’ and what do the relationships between them look like?
- How can we tell a more positive story about what tax is used for? What sort of characters would feature in this alternative story and what do the relationships between them look like?
- What language, formats and creative techniques could be utilised to make taxpayers feel more positively about the tax system?