Tax came into the public spotlight following what I would describe as a first ‘wave of populism’, from about 2010. This followed the financial crisis, and in my view was triggered by the resulting policy of austerity. It led to protests by UK Uncut, the NGO and campaigning coalition, alongside wider public concern about tax avoidance and multinationals.
Yet the level of public understanding of tax continues to be low. A greater level of public awareness of and interest in tax has not led to a more informed debate, nor to a significantly greater public involvement in tax policy. It’s interesting to ask why this progression didn’t take place, and what might be done differently to create a more constructive debate on tax, post-Brexit.
So, what might a constructive debate look like?
It’s worth contrasting the UK with the Irish experience. For example, in Ireland there seems to have been a much greater cross-party acceptance of the need for a favourable corporate tax regime (though the consensus is perhaps beginning to show signs of strain). We’ve seen this in Northern Ireland too, where there has been support from both the DUP and Sinn Fein for a special low rate of corporation tax to attract investment. In sharp contrast, it’s inconceivable that there would be this kind of consensus in the rest of the UK.
Of course, I’m not suggesting we should emulate Ireland on this specific policy, as I think the corporation tax rate is already lower than it needs to be. My point is that Ireland seems to have created the conditions for a healthier public debate on the nuances of taxation, and if we are looking to use Brexit as a catalyst to do the same, it’s worth considering how this has been achieved.
Another issue here is the lack of public awareness and debate of trade-offs in policy making. This tends to lead to unrealistic and rather sterile debate – problems that are not confined to the tax sphere but are perhaps particularly acute because of the complexity of tax.
What else could the government be doing to engage the public?
Consultation over policy has been on the rise since the coalition government introduced a policy-making framework in 2010/11 (usefully discussed here by the Lords Economic Affairs Committee). However, my sense is that this hasn’t resulted in significantly greater public involvement in tax policy.
This may be because some of the key decisions, such as rates, aren’t generally subject to consultation – it’s used much more heavily for more specialist, complex areas of tax. Even when there are consultations on topics that affect large numbers of taxpayers, the range of respondents can be narrow, as many will be daunted by long consultation documents that are perceived to be for a specialist audience.
This points to a clear need for more ‘bridges’ between experts and the public. At present, that space is largely occupied by those who have a particular policy axe to grind, which makes for a very heated polemic and means that a more nuanced public debate is very difficult to achieve.
Does Brexit provide an opportunity for a wider public debate on tax policy?
I would expect Brexit to occupy virtually the whole of the government’s bandwidth over the next few years. As a result, and given the constraints of a minority government, the scope for significant tax reform will be severely limited. On the other hand, this hiatus could provide an opportunity to build a cross-party consensus on some important but controversial issues, such as the difference in taxation between employment and self-employment.