Although some may argue that Brexit will mean little time for politicians and civil servants to focus on other national policy issues, there is also a view that this could be a generational opportunity to reframe and reform the UK’s outdated and cumbersome tax regime.
The report Responsible Tax: New rules for Brexit Britain recognises this opportunity. It builds on the previous efforts by a range of stakeholders to produce consensus on what a responsible tax system looks like, draws a clear connection between tax and society, and reinforces the ineffective manner of policy development hitherto.
Tax is necessary for a vibrant society where all have the opportunity to realise their potential. However, tax policy making, review and governance has not historically drawn out that underlying principle. We can go on with kneejerk political reaction to events or to address the excesses of aggressive tax planning but these often result in poorly thought through tax proposals. A new status quo is required, and Brexit may provide the justification for redesigning our tax regime.
That said, it is important not to rush into redesigning the tax system based on pure political opportunism alone. This is why it is important to take stock of the principles of a good tax system which date back to Adam Smith, but which have also been more recently iterated in the well-received Better Budgets work from the Institute for Government, CIOT and the IFS. Common Vision’s paper builds on some of those themes and looks at how these principles could be applied in the context of Brexit.
One recommendation which I find particularly compelling is the idea of aligning industrial strategy with a tax roadmap. But if the Treasury is not prepared to enact such a roadmap, perhaps business and civil society groups have a role to play. I sit on the Tax Professionals Forum, a body that reports to ministers on the effectiveness or otherwise of policy development and Finance Bill processes. Could a similar group, extended to include input from civil society and a wider group of tax stakeholders, start to convene such a discussion?
I also support the idea of the Office of Tax Simplification (OTS) undertaking a review of tax reliefs. Government receipts are forecast at £716billion in 2016/17 – tax reliefs represent revenue foregone (assuming no behavioural change) of approximately £400billion. This is the elephant in the room of tax policy, and yet tax reliefs are rarely subject to review.
These are some starting points for how we could improve the UK’s tax system and the economy in Brexit Britain as a result.