It is clear that the UK government wishes to secure sufficient flexibility post-Brexit – or, perhaps more accurately, post any transitional/implementation period – to address the specific business and broader economic trends affecting the UK economy. Tax policy is, of course, one of those areas where flexibility, provided that it is implemented correctly, should be beneficial. There is no doubt, for example, that the EU’s state aid regime has been a hurdle for both regional tax incentives and those focused upon entrepreneurial businesses as opposed to multinational companies. No one should underestimate the role of tax competition between different countries which seek to promote each country as a business-friendly (including, of course, a tax-friendly) location both for foreign direct investment by multinational companies and, increasingly, as a destination for global entrepreneurs to establish businesses.
There is, of course, already significant tax competition between EU member states but, increasingly, it will be global competition which matters much more as Europe continues to become a smaller and smaller part of the global economy. At present, European countries are less tax-friendly than many global regimes. Although the UK has more favourable business taxation rates and reliefs than most of its EU competitors, it is well behind many global countries seeking to attract inbound investment, especially investment focused upon the digital economy.
The tax debate between politicians and in the media has become increasingly toxic. Those favouring lower taxation of businesses and improved tax reliefs are often portrayed as favouring a subset of wealthy investors (despite most shares being owned by pension and investment funds with increasingly wide investor bases) or even being somehow opposed to the provision of essential state-financed functions such as health and education. There is a balance to be struck between desirable, flexible and transparent tax competition between countries and undesirable and opaque tax avoidance, but it has not been delivered yet.
I believe there is a role for a country to become the authentic global champion for tariff elimination, free trade and authentic tax competition. Tariffs focus upon protecting producers at the expense of consumers and have substantial economic downsides and few, if any, upsides in the medium/longer term. They should not be viewed as a useful source of fiscal revenues but as a damaging constraint upon growth and prosperity.
Free trade requires the lightest possible regulation to ensure that competition is not subsidised by the state or wrapped in unnecessary, onerous and expensive bureaucracy. Tax competition should be focussed upon tax rates and broad-based tax reliefs but also be responsive to the local economic imperatives. If the Mediterranean countries within the EU27 want to introduce tax incentives to promote regional tax reliefs to reduce their crippling rates of youth unemployment, a post-Brexit UK should not object.
Post-Brexit, the UK should become that global champion and, indeed, no other major developed country has better credentials to be that champion.