With the outcome of David Cameron’s renegotiation attempts imminent and both campaigns on tenterhooks, ready for their official launch, it will soon be ‘all systems go’ as each camp vies for the simple majority needed in a two-question referendum. The most recent polls do not agree on whether the UK will vote to stay by a clear majority or whether it will be quite close. One thing they do agree on is a clear generational divide.
If you weren’t alive the last time the UK had a referendum on whether to remain in the European Union in 1975, you’re much less likely to vote to leave the EU in the next one. That’s the evidence from all the polls recently which suggest that somewhere around two-thirds or even three-quarters of 18-34-year-olds would vote to stay in the union. Even in those polls that suggest the vote in the overall population is close or that ‘Leave’ may be ahead slightly, a look at how this breaks down by age reveals a remarkable generational divide, leading Peter Kellner, President of YouGov, to describe age as one of the ‘big dividing lines’ on the EU along with education and newspaper readership.
Why is this the case? There is little in the way of research although some correlating factors exist. Younger people are less likely to care about immigration than their elders, and indeed this divide itself is increasing according to in-depth longitudinal research by Ipsos MORI. With concern for immigration and Euroscepticism linked, it is perhaps unsurprising that these two gaps co-exist.
Linked to the question of why these two generational gaps exist, is the question of what the implications are for the upcoming referendum and beyond. Given that this vote is about the long-term future of the United Kingdom, it is vital that younger generations’ voices are adequately heard. This means that there should be a strong voter registration and turnout drive.
It also means that campaigns, politicians and media on both sides have a duty to make their case in a way that chimes with the interests and values of younger people and speaks to wider issues such as public services and society more generally. It is unlikely that a ‘Leave’ campaign focused on the need to reduce migration will achieve this. By the same token, if the ‘Remain’ campaign continues to focus on removed, hard-to-grasp issues such as GDP or trade it is unlikely to enthuse anybody regardless of age, but at least most older voters will still head to the ballot box regardless. As we see time after time in elections, this is not true of under-35s.
One lesson from the referendum in Scotland in September 2014 is that the implications of referenda can be more far-reaching and ingrained than simply the outcome of the referendum itself. Regardless of whether the UK votes to leave or remain, the campaigning itself could have a lasting impact not just in heightening attitudes to the EU itself, but related issues such as migration, democracy and security.
The danger is we have a situation, such as in Scotland, where political differences become so entrenched that they no longer feel like differences in opinion but differences in identity. Feelings of being ignored, duped or patronised by the campaigns and politicians could heighten polarised tensions or entrench political indifference. Neither would be good for our democracy.