No one can deny that tax policy for businesses has a much higher public profile than it did five years ago and the forthcoming changes – for good or for bad – as a result of Brexit is bound to keep it in the spotlight for at least the next few years.
The need for enhanced tax transparency sits at the core of today’s tax debate, as politicians across the political spectrum feel the need to respond to the media and, through the media, to the public. There are of course, equally important tax policy considerations for the UK government such as a persistent fiscal deficit, substantial accumulated public debt, and the imperative for our tax rates and reliefs to be globally competitive if the UK economy is to thrive.
So far as multinational corporations are concerned, much of the disquiet has been that some firms appear to be globally profitable, have a significant presence in the UK and a substantial base of UK customers, yet pay no corporation tax here. This might not have anything to do with tax avoidance – it is not difficult to imagine a multinational company which has tight profit margins, intellectual property created and owned overseas, high distribution costs and substantial capital expenditure producing a zero corporation tax liability. However, it seems impossible that this possible analysis can be accepted by anti-globalisation lobbyists and, more importantly, unlikely that it can secure understanding from the British public itself.
For these reasons, I think that it should be accepted across the political spectrum that a corporation tax based on slicing and dicing a multinational corporation’s profits into their component country parts is an impossible task. Instead, a simpler, more transparent taxation based upon these businesses’ UK footprints, sales and employment needs to be identified – one which retains and, indeed, improves the UK’s tax competitiveness.
For many years, HM Treasury has been implacably opposed to the concept of tax hypothecation (defined as wholly meeting the cost of a public service or benefit out of a specific tax). However, hypothecation has something going for it as it has transparency ‘in spades’. For this reason, I think HM Treasury needs to be ‘encouraged’ by Ministers to abandon their opposition to hypothecation and accept that it is not essential to the Exchequer and for the UK economy that all tax revenues pass through it before being allocated to public spending.
Where might this take us? Firstly, there some areas of public spending such as the NHS and the State Pension where public choices and demands could be enhanced if there were to be a clearcut, direct and complete matching of taxes raised and services provided. At the very least, the argument that such essential spending could be improved by reducing, for example, defence spending or overseas aid (depending on political value judgements) would be marginalised if not eliminated. Although national insurance contributions were originally introduced with these objectives in mind, that link has long since been lost if, indeed, it ever existed in reality.
So far as business taxation is concerned, suitable candidates for tax hypothecation could include the annual budget for the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy which, at £14 billion n 2016/17 represented approximately 50% of business rates. Accordingly, if business rates were to be bifurcated into business rates (50%) and a new tax levied on business premises called, for example, ‘industrial strategy tax’ (50%), a roadmap towards business tax hypothecation for BEIS would have been established which would finance its entire expenditure and no more than this.
I am not saying that all taxation should be hypothecated, merely that HM Treasury’s mantra against it should be challenged and that, in some areas, tax hypothecation might strengthen the link between government spending and the taxes raised to pay for it and thereby enhance transparency.