Exiting the EU and entering a new EU-UK agreement present us with a great opportunity to revisit the UK tax system and ask what we need to reform in light of the changing economic uncertainty that Brexit will bring. That’s why UNISON welcomes the recommendations in the new report, Responsible tax: New rules for Brexit Britain? as an important issue in the Brexit debate.
In 2015, it was reported that the poorest fifth of the population lost 37.8% of their income to the HMRC, while the richest fifth paid 34.8% – this was a wider gap than the previous year. The reason why those on the lowest incomes are paying the biggest proportion of their income in tax is because indirect taxes, such as VAT and tax on tobacco, alcohol and fuel are charged at the same rate to all income groups. Is this a fair and progressive tax system or can we reconfigure it to make it fairer for all income groups?
We have also seen continuous attempts by the current government to row back on family tax credit payments for low income families while at the same time there is the perception of it being ‘soft’ on corporate tax avoidance and the use of secret tax havens to hide the income of the rich. This imbalance needs to change. Brexit must not be used to create a global ‘race to the bottom’ in the UK through new corporate tax cuts, nor should it allow for the UK to become a tax haven. Such measures, I believe, will succeed only in driving down the living standards of ordinary workers.
Tax could also be more transparent with respect to the private finance initiative (PFI) schemes. After the Carillion debacle, UNISON responded by saying that the enormous profits being racked up by Private Finance Initiative (PFI) companies should be subject to a new windfall tax, so that much-needed resources can be put back into the UK’s public services. A new windfall tax could prove a lifeline to public services under pressure. UNISON has therefore been supporting amendments to the Finance Bill in the last week, which have been tabled by Stella Creasy MP, to achieve this.
Government cuts to spending have placed schools, hospitals and local councils in dire financial straits – a desperate situation made worse by the huge PFI loan repayments they’re locked into over many years. When many PFI deals were signed by the Treasury, corporation tax stood at 30%, but now it’s 19%. Cuts to the tax rate mean the PFI companies are making even more money than they thought they would and strengthens the case for a windfall tax in my mind. In view of the uncertainty of Brexit, this may become a much more attractive option for its potential to fill the EU funding gaps that will be left after the UK exits the EU.
Making the UK tax system more accessible and easier to understand with proper transparency and scrutiny will encourage the public to participate more in tax policy debates such as these. This in turn will make it more accountable, fair and democratic when legislative and regulatory changes are made.