Today’s Common Vision report, Responsible tax: New rules for Brexit Britain? makes a number of welcome recommendations for tax policy change in the UK. There are three themes which chime neatly with aims and objectives of the Association of Accounting Technicians (AAT) and our 140,000 members – certainty, simplicity and accountability.
Certainty
The proposal to outline an industrial strategy tax roadmap to 2030 is an interesting one and fits neatly with our members’ views, as expressed in the AAT 2018 Policy Reform Survey. Members were given numerous options to choose from as the most important change they would like to see in 2018 and one of the top three was that the government should publish a clear tax strategy and, as far as possible, stick to it.
By setting out government priorities and its approach to tax at the beginning of each Parliament, the public, politicians and other stakeholders could better hold the government to account.
This would provide greater certainty for tax and accountancy professionals and their 12 million clients, whilst assisting the government, especially the Treasury, in providing an agreed direction of travel.
This isn’t a new idea. In 2014, the House of Lords Economic Affairs Committee said, “We continue to believe that tax policy would be developed more coherently if, at the beginning of every government, clear statements were to be published, similar to the 2010 company tax road map. These would give details of the government’s overall strategic aims for different parts of the tax system. We recommend this for the future.”
Although it isn’t a new concept, and the Common Vision report further refines the idea, providing longer-term certainty via a comprehensive tax roadmap is a recommendation that’s time may have come.
Simplicity
In December, HMRC published a list of what it calls ‘minor tax reliefs’ – the little breaks and bonuses that each cost the taxpayer less than £50m. It’s clear that many of these, although not all, could quite easily be removed without any significant policy impact.
These include the unacceptable; reliefs for MPs’ expenses and inheritance tax reliefs on transfers to political parties, as well as the outdated (relief on life insurance contracts taken out before 1984) to those where increasing costs warrant review, for example theatre tax relief which cost £20m in 2014/15 but more than doubled to £50m in 2016/17.
The Common Vision proposal that the Chancellor commissions a comprehensive review of tax reliefs therefore seems very sensible. This should be done on a cross party basis to maximise the chances of success.
Accountability
The proposal to review government structure and apportionment of responsibilities when it comes to tax policy making seems logical and could well prove to be a more effective way for tax measures to be assessed and implemented.
More meaningful consultation wouldn’t go amiss either. Sometimes there is no consultation at all, as with the infamous Philip Hammond decision to increase NICs for the self-employed and its subsequent reversal. Often consultation is wholly inadequate because decisions have already been made but the appearance of consultation must be maintained. This was the case with the recent OPBAS debacle in relation to the new anti-money laundering regulator. Here, the Treasury consulted over the summer holidays in August and the FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) then consulted in the runup to Christmas.
Scrutiny of the tax system is no bad thing as it reduces the chances of unintended consequences whilst increasing the chances of policy success. Common Vision is right that efforts need to be made to extend scrutiny but it works both ways.