“The negotiations will undoubtedly be tough, and there will be give and take on both sides, but we continue to believe that no deal is better than a bad deal for the UK…”
- The Conservative Manifesto 2017
In the absence of direction from the UK Government on what Brexit means for future trade, no one knows what a “bad deal” will look like, let alone post EU negotiations in 2019. What is clear, highlighted by European institutions and member state leaders, is that the UK cannot maintain the current deal within the European Union without the adhering to the four fundamental principles (freedoms) of goods, services, capital and – importantly in the debate – people. As the President of the European Union Donald Tusk has stated: “you cannot have your cake and eat it too…in my opinion, the only real alternative to a hard Brexit is no Brexit.”
The World Bank investigated the potential scenarios of alternative trade deals in their research working paper, Deep Integration and UK-EU Trade Relations. The paper highlights that between the UK and EU, exports account for 51% of goods and services, or $353.1 billion dollars out of $701.4 billion, to the European Union. Also, imports account for 51% of goods and services or $363.7 billion out of $715.5 billion from the European Union. On this analysis alone there will be consequences to the UK economy due to leaving the European Union. The question is to what extent. If the UK does not stay in the Single Market or Customs Union, what does this mean for Britain?
The World Bank looked at Preferential Trade Agreements (PTA) the European Union has undertaken with countries outside of the EU and concludes that many deals do not go beyond the scope of the World Trade Organisation (WTO). In their analysis, the UK would be hit with a 38% drop in goods and a 48% drop in services if an average PTA was signed. With a no deal, the UK would have zero provisions and would have to trade with the EU on Most Favoured Nation (MFN) tariffs which would lead to a 50% reduction in goods and 62% reduction in services (p.18-19).
This provides a crucial insight into the impact these negotiations will have in the UK. The impact of reduced trade will have effect our growth, industries and services. Ultimately, the consequences of these trade negotiations will be felt negatively by everyone. And it will be younger generations that will pick up the pieces.