We know that art has the ability to improve our health and wellbeing. To unlock the regenerative and healing potential of the arts in our lives, we need funders and government to think big. The prize will be a substantial new income stream for the arts sector which could go hand in hand with significant savings to the health budget. To make progress, we must leave some old assumptions behind, find the early wins and prepare for long-term growth in the new normal post-COVID.
There are three key opportunities, but there are pitfalls too – ones that the arts sector needs to address quickly. Let’s start with the old assumptions that are holding us back:
- It’s just the health sector that needs to change. The ‘Creative Health’ report of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Arts, Health & Wellbeing had 10 recommendations. The majority were for the health sector. None were addressed to arts organisations doing arts-and-health work. And yet, there is so much to be done, starting with equipping busy artists and arts organisations to work with a complex health system. Aesop now has an accredited arts-and-health training course with Canterbury Christ Church University.
- Arts-and-health work is a compromise: the more you engage with health issues, practices and systems, the less artistic scope there is. This is a false tension. At its best, artists and clinicians collaborating on arts-and-health programmes set up virtuous circles between high-quality artistic practice and health improvement.
- Growing arts-and-health programmes into services, available to all who need them, will undermine artistic and social quality. The fear is that going to scale means a large bureaucracy, remote from beneficiaries and a one-size-fits-all approach, insensitive to local culture and not involving local people. Both are unjustified. The health sector now uses the concept of ‘universal personalised care’. The arts can learn from this.
Underpinning each of these assumptions is the long battle over the role, worth, and purpose of art. It is a battle played in the last 20 years in DCMS reports, Arts Council strategies, and AHRC enquiries. The battle of ideas limps on but what are we practitioners to do? Aesop’s experience from Dance to Health – an arts solution to older people’s falls – has been heartening. From this we’ve identified three further keys for unlocking the potential of culture within wellbeing:
- Make the cost-saving case with confidence: Significant health savings and a substantial new income stream for the arts can go hand in hand, and health sector interest in working with the arts is growing. Last year 74% of GPs agreed that public engagement with the arts can make a significant contribution to the prevention agenda (up from 66% in 2018). 54% agree that arts-based interventions can be a cost-effective way to deliver primary care to the public to improve health outcomes (44% in 2018). A Sheffield Hallam University evaluation of Dance to Health, identified a potential annual cost saving of £79 million for the NHS.
- Build reliable evidence: Getting the right evidence in place will open the door to health. We must work with specialist health and arts researchers on the practical questions that health partners will need answers to. Often this starts with the question ‘does my arts programme improve health?’ We have to be careful here. For example, Aesop now knows that Dance to Health’s special dance practice reduces older people’s falls by 58%. However, the wider statement ‘dance reduces falls’ is not true. A major research study found social dancing such as folk and ballroom did not prevent falls. Other key questions need answers. There are funds to support this research, starting with the National Institute for Health Research (with its budget of over £1 billion).
- Enable mutual understanding and collaboration: The third opportunity is to find the sweet spot where artistic excellence and health improvement meet. It’s a place where artists have the chance to make work and develop their creative practice, and health professionals can best fulfil their calling; and where health and arts professionals can spark off each other to achieve even better things and build mutual understanding and respect. Making common cause between the health and arts sectors is not just about high-level partnership. It’s about daily collaboration.
COVID-19 is a tragedy: deaths, traumatic illness, job losses and increased domestic violence. Good is coming out of it too: a reminder of the power of collective action, a new determination to achieve a green economic recovery, new forms of digital collaboration. Let’s make sure that the arts sector grows, offering unforgettable artistic experiences and improving the nation’s health – and not just for the lucky few, but for everyone. We have many brilliant artists in this country ready and able to make a vital contribution. Echoing Arts Council England’s 2020-30 strategy, ‘Let’s create’ artistic solutions for all who need them.
By Tim Joss|October 19th, 2020|Culture and Connection