Skip to content
Me
Me

Hypothecation: beyond the ‘factory model’ of taxation

Loading...

by

Danny Dorling

4 October 2018

There is an argument that we should oppose hypothecation on the grounds that it is misleading, reducing the economy to a ‘factory model’ of inputs and outputs.

The hypothecation of taxation implies that politics works like an factory making many products. This factory model of taxation implies that you get out of the economy what you put in. Taking the example of a cereal factory, if you Increase the inputs of oats and wheat and sugar and ramp up the amount of cardboard you buy, more packages of cereal will come out of the other end of the production line. In essence, you give the public power over the inputs and they will get more of what they want.

The factory model of taxation is misleading in a similar way to how misleading it is to think that the economics of a whole economy is similar to the economics of a household. That household – or ‘handbag’ – model of economics suggests that if you are frugal, and spend less, you will prosper.

There is, of course, some truth in all models. The handbag model of economics is an analogy that will at times appear to be pertinent. For instance, at some point it will not be possible for the United States of America to carry on spending vastly more money than it raises in taxes every year, increasing its national debt to astronomical levels. However, the reason it will not be able to do that is not because the United States economy is like the household budget of a family. For a state, which is made up of many millions of households, money does not play the same role as the money you might have in your handbag. A country’s current account does not determine what its people are able to buy at the shops that same day.

The factory model of taxation, like the handbag model of economics, is initially attractive and intuitive because it reduces a process to something you think you understand well, although most people have never been in a factory and most of us run our household economics on debt. For example, I have a mortgage and no one calls me profligate.

Consider health care. The factory model of health care implies that the more you spend on health care the better your health will be. I am not saying that the opposite is the case – just that it is not as direct a process as simply putting more in to get more out.

The USA is, again, a useful example for this. Far more is spent on healthcare in the USA, per head, than in any other country in the world. As much is spent from the country’s public purse on schemes like Medicare and Medicaid as is spent privately, and yet the results are not good. On closer inspection it turns out not to be health spending that best predicts health outcomes in the separate states of the USA and other affluent countries of the world, but the influence of factors such as historical levels of economic inequality, especially income inequality.

Of course, you have to consider multiple issues at once when considering tax. Health spending matters to improve health, but so many other factors also contribute to health outcomes. For example, housing policies to ensure that doctors and nurses can afford to live near their patients. Affordable housing is required so that most of the taxes spent on healthcare do not simply end up being wasted on higher salaries used to pay the rent to private landlords or financing mortgages so that home can be purchased from an older generation who will be cash-rich but health-poor.

The same applies to education policy. Again, it is not just the amount that is spent on education that contributes to the education levels of the population as a whole. When societies are more mixed, children end up better educated.

Social policy is not like a cereal factory. All the inputs go in and all the outputs come out, but they are mixed up in the middle in ways that we are still learning about. All this lends itself to an argument against hypothecation of taxes, which is too heavily reductive about inputs and outputs. However, there is one case were the argument for hypothecation is stronger, and that is in the introduction of new taxes. This is a concept I explore in part two of this blog.

Share this article

ABOUT THE Project

Loading...

The Responsible Tax Lab

The Responsible Tax Lab is a long term programme focusing on how businesses and civil society can work together to design and encourage a responsible tax system. The Lab launched in December 2016, drawing on Common Vision’s previous experience of convening people and organisations who want to be proactive and aspirational in developing and providing the practical ideas, tools and resources that would make our future tax system fit-for-purpose.

Tax hypothecation is a growing subject of public and political discussion. While many economists and commentators have previously been sceptical of hypothecated models, there is growing recognition of the need to introduce new accountability mechanisms to assist trust in revenue authorities and tax morale, and with it potential improvements in compliance. We set out to explore the practicalities and implications of hypothecation and whether a hypothecated tax system in the UK could contribute towards higher levels of public trust and clearer accountability of monies raised.

How can business and civil society work together to restore trust in the tax system?
Find Out More
Loading...

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Danny Dorling

Danny Dorling is the Halford Mackinder Professor of Geography at St Peter's College, Oxford. He was previously a professor of Geography at the University of Sheffield. Danny is the author of "Inequality and the 1%", and has published with colleagues more than a dozen books on issues related to social inequalities in Britain and several hundred journal papers. Much of this work is available open access, and concerns issues of housing, health, employment, education and poverty.

Find out more

Sign up to our newsletter

We believe in using the power of positive ideas to shift the narrative about the future away from toxic, angry debates and towards shared ambition and collaborative action.

Facebook-f Twitter Linkedin Youtube
  • 27 Dingley Place, London. EC1 8BR
  • hello@covi.org.uk

Common Vision UK is a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales. Company Number 08837291.

Copyright 2026 © All rights reserved.

Read our Privacy Policy here.

  • Home
  • About
  • Projects
  • Events
  • Articles
  • People
  • Library
  • Home
  • About
  • Projects
  • Events
  • Articles
  • People
  • Library
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.