No one likes paying tax. Increased council tax bills are dropping through our letterbox. Council tax is the biggest individual tax demand most of us will get and might now include a social care top up. But, there’s evidence that attitudes are changing on our willingness to pay tax.
The topic of hypothecated taxes, where items are individualised is therefore an attractive one. Who, for example, wouldn’t pay more to support our underpaid carers and nurses? We all know, or should know, that the crisis of social care means unless we reform public finances, the wheels may fall off the public sector’s financing cart. But are we (and by ‘we’ I mean ordinary citizens) happy about taxes rising? We have become used to services of a certain standard. But do we want to pay for them? And if not ‘us’…then who?
I have some real concerns about hypothecation. It could become a tool of pressure groups (such as the TaxPayers’ Alliance) to promote a ‘choice’ in what you are taxed for. The implication here is that if tax is a choice and it is decided that less tax is a good thing, it could become a route towards calls for funding ONLY the deserving, and not the undeserving poor.
Adding an element of choice in tax could also be used by aggressive campaigners, such as ‘nationalists’, to try and exclude the most vulnerable or to deny essential support for ‘un-populist’ causes. It could, for instance, support the campaigns of pacifists unwilling to pay for national defence, or green campaigners refusing to pay for nuclear power. Hypothecation could become a slippery slope towards greater social division.
If people were given the choice, or information, about how an ‘additional’ tax was spent, might they be willing to pay more? Evidence from a poll held in 2014 in Scotland supported this supposition. I too would pay more tax, but what I really want is for it to be well spent.
Might hypothecation help the UK move towards the Scandinavian model of a strong social contract? That of higher taxes coupled with more effective and efficient levels of service, and more public scrutiny. Such a model, I believe, with economies of scale AND good governance, for things like the NHS, education or policing is preferable to an individualised (privatised) provision of such essential services. These services are, in effect, our collective insurance scheme against the crippling cost of healthcare, education or crime prevention, that we may all need at an unknown time in the future.
In an era of insecure employment, zero-hour contracts and wage differentials between men and women, the Scandinavian tax model could positively impact those at the coalface of the NHS and social care more than a pay rise would. But does hypothecation build that social contract or not? I’m not sure.
Many hope that good accountability and clarity over where tax goes means less tax avoidance. News from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), where tax avoidance, poor governance and corruption are endemic, provides one very small example. Other evidence exists and that is perhaps more relevant to the UK. Yet, the point is well made within the article on the DRC: “Research shows participation is more effective than penalties in taxation compliance”.
To me, hypothecation, if it occurs, should be all about rebuilding trust in our fragile democracy. It should seek to clarify the links between the services we receive, the taxes we pay and the people we elect to oversee public bodies.
If that is the primary driver, then experiments in hypothecation may be useful. But, it needs to be balanced with education on how tax and public spending works. It should also be situated squarely within local democratic control – not decided from the top, where it can be influenced by powerful lobbies.
So, how could hypothecation be made local? Parish councils provide one real-life example where a form of hypothecation already exists. Parishes and town councils can raise their precept to meet local priorities and thereby also build the prominence of their bottom-tier democratic culture, such as in Buckfastleigh.
But, tax is complex. Can citizens grasp technical language like ‘hypothecation’? (I had to look it up too!!) Fortunately, there are examples that they can – the RSA’s Citizens’ Economic Council has explored just such topics. The same could be done for hypothecation. A citizens’ inquiry may be good fora in which to debate it with citizens, rather than impose it on them.
My work on participatory budgeting and on deliberative methods of public service redesign has demonstrated that this topic matters, at least to me. A tax system is the basis of a civilised democracy and democracy works best, in my experience, the closer it takes place to the people who will reap the benefits and pay the price.
Paying tax is good. Believe me.