For a number of years now, the CIOT has been calling for an end to the traditional Budget Day Pantomime. No more ‘rabbits from hats’ – surprise announcements of detailed changes already worked up in secret. Or consultation held too late in the process to smooth out all but the roughest edges.
True, it’s tempting to be seen to set the agenda. But do favourable headlines last? Post-Budget u-turns have been common in recent years – the pasty tax, the extra duty on granny flats, the increase in national insurance for the self-employed having provoked particular media frenzy.
Most changes survive, the difficulties brazened out and adding to the complexity of the tax system. The exponential growth in the tax code (approaching 20,000 pages) is outstripping HMRC’s IT capabilities.
Real changes to big things involving money, and human behaviour, need intelligent planning and significant support. Or at the very least the policy-making process around the Budget should enable people to come to an educated understanding that alternatives aren’t perfect either. This can only be achieved through consultation.
The 2019 Conservative Manifesto called for everyone to pay their fair share of tax; no increase in the ‘rate’ of income tax, VAT or national insurance; and spending increases that are now referred to as ‘levelling up’ the economy. If spending were to increase to the levels of, say, Germany – a successful and undoubtedly capitalist Western economy – this might entail tens of billions of pounds a year more tax.
The Manifesto promised a review of Entrepreneurs Relief (that can cut capital gains tax rates on business to 10%). But does it help small businesses to grow above the VAT threshold, or take on their first employee, while avoiding potential negative consequences such as the bureaucratic implications? Even total abolition would save less than £3bn per year. Sadly, the fact that this has gone many years without review is not the exception, but the norm when it comes to tax reliefs.
The continued emphasis on ‘fair shares’, and ‘levelling up’ raise bigger, more fundamental questions, not least in relation to:
- Working. Employers pay 13.8% in employers’ national insurance on salaries, and have the hassle of administering PAYE. No wonder many workers have been moved off payroll – and into corporate structures to save even more tax. The current response is ever tighter anti avoidance rules – but is sticking plaster enough? Is it right that changing legal arrangements leads to such big tax differences, and if it is, how can we define the borderlines clearly and enforcibly?
- Living. If you own and occupy your home, you won’t pay income tax on the benefit. But if you pay rent, this comes out of taxed income. (If you have to work in London, but could only afford to buy in your home region, you can’t set the rent you pay against tax on the rent you earn.) Is all this fair?
- Spending. Our VAT system is riddled with holes – it’s not paid on food, private education or medicine, or financial services for example. We should at least ask, why isn’t it charged on everything? The top 10% pay 20% of VAT. They also buy (and partly waste) more food than the poor. Is blanket VAT relief an effective way of helping anyone?
- Owning. Wealth is even more unequally distributed than income. Yet much of it – whether agricultural land, or the mobile assets of a wealthy ‘non-dom’, are largely sheltered from most capital taxes. There are good reasons behind this, but are we getting the best trade-offs between competing objectives here?
These questions need big conversations, not half-baked and tinkering surprises. And having those big conversations in a responsible, inclusive and consultative way is a long-term challenge for the Chancellor, but something which could start on Budget Day.