The concept of hypothecation, where revenues from specific taxes would be ringfenced for a particular expenditure purpose – and publicly communicated in this way – has become the subject of growing interest and attention from politicians, public bodies and the press. It is increasingly cited as a potential way to address the challenge of funding the rising demand on health and social care services. There is also growing public interest in how hypothecation could act as tool to legitimise tax increases and increase public engagement and trust in the tax system.
This is by no means the first time hypothecation finds itself in vogue – over the course of history the concept has repeatedly entered the imaginations of those looking for new solutions to public funding challenges. And hypothecation is already used in various forms and guises in the UK and internationally. Yet it has traditionally been unpopular with many policy experts and economists because of notable challenges, relating to complexity, transparency, and public perceptions, with which it is associated. As a concept it remains fairly divisive, with ardent proponents and sceptics, and not many views in between.
One of the reasons behind these polarised views is that proponents and commentators of hypothecation are often talking at cross purposes. There is often confusion over what is actually meant by hypothecation, with different understandings of how a specific tax (such as a healthcare tax) would work in practice. ‘Strong’ hypothecation – whereby the tax would wholly cover the cost of the service – would mean that all spending for the service may be tied to a single tax revenue, while at the other end of the scale, ‘weak’ hypothecation’ refers to when one or both of these conditions does not apply.
In a new report from the Responsible Tax Lab we look at different defintions, and the differences between them. We also consider the advantages and drawbacks of hypothecation in its different forms. It has the potential to generate public trust and confidence in the system if used appropriately, but there are concerns to consider around how hypothecation could undermine the social contract which underpins the tax system, and how it could remove government’s flexibility and ability to respond to pubic finance pressures.
Drawing on some examples and previous experiences of hypothecated revenue models, the report outlines a series of goals for which hypothecation could be used, and the questions, or ‘tests’ that policymakers could apply to these when considering whether hypothecation is the best answer. Different means other than hypothecated models may be just as suitable and effective to achieve the same goals.
Although it has potential as an idea, hypothecation is not a silver bullet solution, whether for revenue raising purposes or as a tool to increase public trust and accountability. There are some circumstances where it may be used to achieve specific benefits, but there are a number of fundamentals that must be addressed to underpin the success of any hypothecated tax. These include good communication and public education, not only about the objectives of the specific tax, but the purpose of the tax system overall. As with other tax mechanisms, rigorous policymaking is key to its effectiveness, from the pre-implementation consultation process, to scrutiny, transparency around implementation successes and challenges, and defined impact measurement. Hypothecation needs to be considered in the context of how the current tax system works, so any benefits to public trust and accountability would be undermined by an overly complex system, so simplicity is also important. These are challenges, but they are also opportunities to take a holistic view of the tax system. In this sense perhaps hypothecation is a lever, not a solution, to reap long-term societal and democratic benefits.
Read the full report, Follow the money: Is the time right for (more) tax hypothecation? With thanks to PwC for supporting this publication.