Hypothecation is an important debate, but should be one that is built upwards – through freedoms and flexibilities on council taxation, or local income taxes, or possibly, local social care taxes. Though little direct research has been done its been anecdotally observed, good participation increases willingness to trust government, and by implication, I would argue, pay our taxes for causes we believe in.
Attending a recent conference in Sweden, it was pointed out to me by one of the delegates that most Swedish tax is levied locally through local income taxes. What’s more, local governments receive 80% of their income from local taxation, rather than the derisory 20% or so of UK local government tax revenue – known as “council tax” – raised through local property taxes.
This localised method of tax collection insulates Swedish local governments and their local services from the vagaries of increasingly populist national politicians, who often promise low taxes and high quality services for citizens without the ability to make the numbers add up (see the recent UKIP call for a NHS identity card to prevent health tourism). This is a marginal but emotive problem that undermines rather than reinforces the National Health Service – even though it’s been shown such ‘populist’ policies are based on fake news.
A more local tax system results in higher quality services. The immediacy of the link between services and taxation make for a more mature and stable ‘tax contract’, as well as citizens’ willingness to pay into, and receive back, good public services – in sharp contrast to the UK’s heavily centralised tax systems. Most of the Swedish taxes fell into a band of between 30% and 35% despite the huge flexibility allowed to the local councils. While this is still quite high compared to UK income tax rates, these local government are a significant economic force, and a very high employer of women at good rates of pay.
Overall, local income tax is rapidly recycled back into the local economy, reducing social inequalities and benefiting all. In stark comparison, the UK’s health services – which are designed and driven from the top – have some of the worst working conditions and pay rates for women. It is worth noting that Sweden’s mixed economy effectively delivers multiple public services through its private sector. So high levels of public tax, great public services, and a mixed economy are compatible, as long as accountability is kept local.
In 2013, 12% of health care was financed by Swedish county councils but carried out by private care providers. An agreement guarantees that patients are covered by the same regulations and fees that apply to municipal care facilities. But I believe it also allows for flexible combined health and social care commissioning governed by locally elected officials, rather than by publicly employed NHS managers doing their own thing. This brings to my mind some of the political economy work of Elinor Ostrom. In considering ‘common pool resources’ like land, or other environmental common pool goods, Ostrom came up with a set of principles for self government based on fostering local autonomy to decides rules within this ‘common pool’. If we assume a tax base is just another common pool resource – something we all have a stake in and contribute to, and draw benefit from – then maybe this points towards an under considered aspect of hypothecation: that the debate should move beyond single issues to consider ‘tax ecosystems’ operating for mutual benefit and at a scale that citizens can influence.
Ostrom proposed eight principles for common pool resource management, including building public responsibility to govern this common resource through an interconnected, nested tier system, and ensuring the rules governing the common goods match the needs and conditions necessary for citizens on a local level.
For me, this is a fruitful area for taking the debate on tax hypothecation: seeing hypothecation as a process of devolution, accountability and local responsiveness. It is an approach that allows taxes to be seen as social, or common pool resources that must be managed carefully and shared out fairly – rather than tax being seen as the centralised and unavoidable demands of a resource hungry, and largely unaccountable, un-transparent national bureaucracy.
I don’t think privatisation and market based solutions will drive efficiency into public services or reduce the cost of said services. This is often proposed by the big four accountancy firms, who then earn huge incomes from marketising the NHS. It is also often put forth by populist politicians who propose lower taxes are inevitably a good thing, without the numbers to back it up.
I do favour a locally based ‘mixed economy’ and Ostrom presents a strong rebuttal to a neo-liberalist ‘tragedy of the commons is a fact so let’s privatise everything’ culture. The Swedish model of local governance and local taxes offers a strong example as well. So, why not think about local hypothecation, before taking it to national level?