Brexit represents a conundrum for tax policymakers. On the one hand, leaving Europe provides the opportunity to abandon EU restrictions on the UK tax system, allowing it to evolve to meet our own needs. On the other hand, with thousands of regulations to rewrite, complex negotiations to be undertaken and all of this in the context of global economic uncertainty where the UK wishes to continue to play a vital role, there is a serious risk that the opportunity to clean up the UK tax system will be missed because of lack of resources and too much busy-ness in other areas.
Common Vision has today published a report Responsible tax: New rules for Brexit Britain?
My own first-hand experience tells me that people have major concerns about the UK tax system:
- The UK tax system is too complex
- People are losing faith in the UK tax system
- What do we want the UK tax system to do?
- What about business taxes?
In its report, Common Vision addresses these concerns by proposing ideas for improving the tax policy-making process and the resulting public debate in the short, medium and long term:
Certainty
Recalibrating Britain’s economic policy alongside Brexit may provide an opportunity to have a coherent ‘theory of change’ which underpins tax policies. Common Vision proposes that a joint sub-committee led by HM Treasury and the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) outlines an industrial strategy tax roadmap to 2030.
There is also a case for a ‘sunset clause’ to be applied to all new tax reliefs outlined in such a roadmap, so that the impact proposed is timebound and subject to a review within a three to five-year period, for example.
Simplicity
To aid public understanding and therefore legitimacy of the tax system, Common Vision proposes that the Chancellor commissions a comprehensive review of tax reliefs prior to the UK’s formal exit from the European Union. This could be conducted by the Office of Tax Simplification.
In the longer term, this might be extended to a review of the opportunities for tax simplification more broadly.
Scrutiny
In the short term, Common Vision proposes that tax policy implementation is subject to additional scrutiny mechanisms via parliamentary select committees, rather than the main challenger role resting solely with the Treasury Select Committee and, more recently, the Public Accounts Committee. This is particularly important at a time when unprecedented executive power lies with the government.
Common Vision also recommends more support for parliamentary vehicles, such as the Public Accounts Committee and the Treasury Select Committee, through resources for parliamentary libraries and committee staffers, to enhance their capacity to challenge measures.
Accountability
In the longer term, Common Vision advocates a review of government structure and apportionment of responsibilities when it comes to tax policy making. With increased national competencies on tax, it may be more effective for tax measures to be assessed and implemented as a joint effort between the Treasury and other government departments, similar to other policy instruments.
Civil society has a role to play in extending efforts to scrutinise the tax system. Common Vision encourages civil society and business groups alike to embrace their scrutiny role within the policy-making process.
William Simon, US Treasury Secretary 1974 – 1977, famously observed that, “the nation should have a tax system that looks like someone designed it on purpose.” The Common Vision report is required reading for anyone who is concerned to ensure that the UK tax system is fit for purpose after Brexit.