The creative sector excels at problem solving, reacting to the unusual and bringing a proactive attitude to a reactive situation. This social and creative resilience has been proven during the pandemic. The sector’s financial resilience is, however, less certain. There is much to learn from the vulnerabilities and gaps in support cultural organizations experienced in the initial stages of the pandemic, as well as clear opportunities for organisations and funders to rethink their relationship to risk and lay firmer foundations for a sustainable future.
To date, Prosper North has helped 55 cultural heritage organisations across the North of England. We’ve had the privilege of supporting these organisations develop their business models prior to the pandemic as well as supporting them through lockdown and recovery. Through mentoring and peer support the Prosper North business development programme aims to enable these organisations to adapt at to the ‘new normal’. Regardless of the area of the work they deliver, all 55 organisations have taken on the challenge of COVID-19 bravely. The pause in delivery has given many leaders time and space to think strategically about their core purpose and value going forward.
Whilst some have stayed buoyant, others are struggling acutely. For instance, Prosper North member York Museums Trust – an independent charity responsible for York Castle Museum, York Art Gallery, the Yorkshire Museum, York Museum Gardens and York St Mary’s on behalf of City of York Council – recently announced potential redundancies. This highlights the immediate and crippling impact of lost earned income, compounded by the challenges of rapidly sourcing alternative funding in a highly competitive environment. As the Government’s £1.57bn Culture Recovery Fund begins to be implemented, there will be a temporary solution to many organisations’ financial pressures. However, arts and cultural leaders will have to prepare for the longer-term challenges and opportunities which may emerge in the post-COVID economic landscape.
So, in a funding landscape where there is less to go around and an evidently a greater need, what can organisations do? At Prosper North we believe that cultural leaders will need to diversify their income so that they can adapt to micro and macro changes in the economy. Giving serious consideration to blended finance could be a sea change for the sector. Traditionally risk averse and wary of borrowing finance, cultural organisations have been hesitant adopters of loans and social investment. However, there are now some excellent packages available. For example, Prosper North is aligned to the Northern Cultural Regeneration Fund, managed by The Key Fund, which offers a grant blended with a long term, low-interest loan to cultural organisations who have a social purpose. Options like this might provide greater long-term financial stability for organisations once the emergency funding runs out.
Alongside taking up emerging grant and loan opportunities, organisations will also need to plan strategically for how they build the social and economic case for the sustained public funding it needs. The strongest case for a well-designed, ongoing support and funding package may come from organisations who have survived and thrived in the pandemic, including those who have been able to develop their business models with the support of programmes such as Prosper North. These may often be the smaller organisations who had what Common Vision’s report terms ‘agile resilience’, and were more quickly able to adapt than larger institutions.
By building evidence for what worked, we can also start to see where long-standing gaps in support were. Just one of these is training and investment to build digital infrastructure in heritage sites, cultural venues and arts organisations. For those organisations who do receive public investment, whether as emergency grants or longer-term funding, robust and evidence-driven evaluation will be vital to make the continued case for the social and economic value of investing in culture.
As we navigate the months ahead, I hope that we will be able to implement positive changes in the funding landscape needed to lay the foundations for the long-term resilience of cultural organisations across the UK.