There has been a recent increase in policy discussions regarding the possibilities of devolved tax policymaking and tax collection in the UK. This has in part been triggered by the impending devolution of income tax powers to Holyrood following the 2016 Scotland Act; however, the discussion is also being had by the Welsh government, in Northern Ireland, and in cities across England.
The UK has historically had a highly centralised tax system. The arguments in favour of increased tax devolution include the idea that it could grant authorities a level of autonomy that could end up bolstering local democracy. However, would decentralised tax policy help or hinder regional inequality? Could it lead to a ‘race to the bottom’ between localities within the UK?
At an event co-hosted by the Chartered Institute of Taxation and the Institute of Fiscal Studies, a panel of experts considered the benefits, costs and risks of tax devolution in the UK.
The event began with a presentation from David Phillips, associate director at the IFS, who set out the common arguments for tax devolution, as well as the risks and challenges. A key challenge is around whether local authorities currently have the capacity for new tax powers, and whether devolution could lead to erosion of the tax base as different localities compete with each other on tax policies.
Dr Neil Lee, LSE associate professor of economic geography, said the key caveat to consider is the quality, effectiveness and leadership of local government. Though a “Detroit situation” – where a city mismanages its new autonomy from national government into bankruptcy – is unlikely to occur in the UK, large parts of the country are currently being managed by local councils that struggle to fulfill their basic mandates with the current funding on hand, an issue Neil noted is mostly due to austerity and the makeup of national industrial strategy.
Joanna Walker, CIOT’s technical officer for Scottish taxes, noted that understanding how new regional policies will align or diverge with existing national policy is of utmost importance. She pointed out that there currently remains some confusion in Scotland as to whether the Scottish or UK Parliament holds the responsibility for certain taxes. A consistent, logical framework for the devolution process could help provide a stronger likelihood of initial success. Transparent collaboration around tax policy negotiations, particularly around the type and scale of devolved taxes, is an important prerequisite.
Julia Goldsworthy, director of strategy for the West Midlands Combined Authority, said fiscal devolution presents an important opportunity for the combined authorities, particularly in relation to the generation of new revenue streams and the ability to attract both public and private investment. Echoing Joanna Walker’s comments on the need for a consistent framework, she called for a long term approach to planning for tax devolution.
Chairing the panel, Helen Miller from the IFS added that ultimately, there is not right answer as to whether the UK should or shouldn’t devolve its tax policy. But any discussion must ensure the right questions are asked about the practicalities of both the process of handing over control to regional government and and how best to design a truly sustainable devolution framework.
Something that was touched on by speakers, but which merits further consideration, is whether tax devolution could encourage greater citizen engagement or even direct participation in the decision making process. An interesting point made was around how levels of public support for devolution are a key driver, as with the Scottish case. How public attitudes across the UK can shape tax devolution and build trust and and accountability, is a theme that we want to investigate through the Responsible Tax Lab’s work next year.