Where exactly does responsibility lie for paying taxes, and ensuring taxes are paid? Does it sit with the legal system to set practical and enforceable legislation, the individual and their moral code, corporate practice or political reform?
This longstanding legal and ethical conundrum was the subject of a recent conference held at the University of Copenhagen, which brought together a range of views from academics, lawyers, policy makers and human rights experts. The event considered whether tax behaviour is a consideration in businesses’ broader corporate social responsibility policies, and how companies go about selecting and defining the moral norms around just what responsible tax really means. Speakers at the conference approached these issues from a wide variety of philosophical and practical angles.
The moral and ethical principles which underpin responsible tax policy and behaviour was the most prevalent theme across a range of panel sessions. Many speakers referred to how societal norms often inevitably become codified in law. But Grace Perez-Navarro, deputy director to the OECD’s Centre for Tax Policy and Administration, made the case that questions of ethics and morality could distract companies from the benefits they are most likely to care about. Instead, she argued that approaching discussions of responsible tax with the view of compliance to a “reasonable interpretation of the law” – and not the “literal letter of the law” – would be the most effective way of spurring them towards adopting more responsible tax policy.
The problem with sticking to a purely legal perspective however, according to professor Hans Gribnau at Tilburg University, is that this “blocks thought” on the subject. “Taxes are meant to sustain society, not the state – the state is only an intermediary to do all kinds of good things for society”, he posited, although acknowledging that while the Scandinavian public is used to that concept, other countries’ citizens might not be quite as receptive.
Professor Sigrid Hemels from the Netherlands argued paying taxes supports a country’s legal system – and a stable legal system is essential to maintaining well-functioning financial markets. But on the other hand tax planning – even the aggressive variety – may be seen as a responsibility, or obligation to shareholders. But he also noted that there is a trend amongst shareholders towards expecting companies to act in the interests of society.
For the OECD, divergent policy language remains a key hurdle to including responsible tax efforts within the wider framework of CSR (corporate social responsibility). Grace Perez-Navarro said corporations generally didn’t see tax compliance as equating to good corporate governance when the OECD was updating its Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises in 2011. But as CSR definitions expand to include environmental elements, and business and human resources elements, she argued that it is time for taxation to become part of the global CSR discussion.
In a conciliatory closing speech, Denmark’s Minister for Taxation Karsten Lauritzen (who arrived by bicycle) challenged the idea that corporations are uniquely responsible for ensuring shareholder satisfaction. The minister emphasised the necessity of a trust-based tax system – because “trust makes everything run a little smoother”. International companies’ abuse of this fundamental trust between citizens, corporations and politicians would only backfire, he warned. “We are in a world where doing nothing is moving backwards”.
The Conference on Fair Taxation and Corporate Social Responsibility took place on the 4th of October, was hosted by the Danish university alongside Faculty of Law by FIRE – Fiscal Relations Research Group, Lund University, and Hanken School of Economics. It was co-financed by the Nordic Tax Research Council.