Thanks to automatic enrolment, millennials are now saving for retirement. But they’re not saving enough. Minimum contribution levels of 8% see millennials under-saving, especially women. The gender pay gap is also mirrored in how much men and women put towards their savings. Little is being done about these problems by millennial savers themselves.
The problem as we identify it is one of perceived relevance. Millennials’ attention is relentlessly in demand. As referenced in the recent trends paper from Common Vision, current financial insecurity and the next near-term financial priority such as a mortgage are far more central to millennials’ planning. For retirement saving to be taken seriously, it needs to sit alongside those priorities.
At ShareAction we carried out research to understand how to hook millennial savers into a conversation about their pension. We found that a primary barrier is pensions being understood solely in terms of retirement. Millennials experience a range of psychological biases that hinder thinking about the future. A distance to retirement saving exists.
But our pensions aren’t just about retirement. They are invested in the companies that create the products, services and infrastructure that make up our day-to-day lives. Moreover, our pension savings are hugely influential, with nearly half of all investments in the UK coming from pension savings. What our pensions do in addition to preparing us for retirement, is build the world around us right now.
For pensions to assume relevance, we have to tell a different story. We have to foreground the huge, present impact of our savings on the world. Millennials’ pensions are invested in FTSE100 companies doing good and bad. Big firms not paying the living wage as well as those who are investing heavily in greening their business.
Why does this have a good chance of success? Millennials are value-driven, more environmental and socially conscious than other demographics. The need to save for retirement competes with these values for millennial attention. But this isn’t necessary. The two can join up. Our pensions can become a way for millennials to express their values. Indeed, research by Nordea suggests that moving into sustainable funds can be up to 27 times more effective in reducing your carbon footprint than other behavioural changes.
Millennials’ savings often don’t have a positive impact. Less than 1% of people switch into ethical fund options and sit in default funds that track oil, tobacco and arms companies. Yet nationally representative research by DFID shows that 56% of savers would switch into a sustainable pension if given the option.
Many savers don’t know they have the option to switch. If pensions aren’t relevant, savers are unlikely to research the options they have. In addition, pension providers aren’t exactly up front about them.
If pensions were talked about in impact terms, with fund options more clearly spelled out, the effect on millennial financial resilience could be significant. Research by Franklin Templeton demonstrates that when this happens, savers become interested in their pension. What’s more, on recognising they can have a positive impact they are likely to want to contribute more towards their retirement. 45% of 22-38 year olds would be motivated to increase their contributions, becoming more financially resilient as a consequence.
Lastly, through message testing we found that it is millennial women who are especially interested in the potential positive impact of pensions. Yet when you look at data of who is actually switching into ethical funds, it tends to be men. The usual explanation for this dissonance is that on a general level men have higher levels of financial confidence, and are more engaged with their money. This makes them likelier to switch. Millennial women are exactly the demographic at risk of under-saving through a pensions pay gap.
A new story that makes pensions relevant needs to be told.