The potential use of hypothecated taxation has gained increasing popularity amongst commentators, most notably several think tanks. The UK Treasury supposedly despises the concept. As this debate intensifies, politicians generally appear to be rather split on the subject.
However, largely unnoticed, the Chancellor’s 2018 Budget included a commitment to hypothecate English Vehicle Excise Duty (VED). It has, until now, been commonly referred to as “road tax”, a description many members of the public wrongly believe means the revenue is already then spent solely on building, maintaining and improving roads.
But whether or not this new commitment announced by the Chancellor marks a policy shift towards hypothecated taxation, as some have long argued for, remains to be seen. Unfortunately, the cynic in me thinks this move is more about convenience than any ideological change. After all, Vehicle Excise Duty is predicted to decline substantially over the next 10 to 15 years as more people switch to electric cars, whose owners pay lower rates of VED. Furthermore, the amount of money raised by the road tax already falls short of the total sum invested in the road network: it raises around £6 billion a year. In comparison, the National Roads Fund will invest £28.8 billion into the road network between 2020 and 2025.
This doesn’t appear to be hypothecation in the strictest sense, although this is one of the problems with the concept, as Daniel Lyons, Deloitte’s Head of Tax, rightly highlighted in his recent blog for the Responsible Tax Lab. It is inevitable that differences will surface between the optimal amount that needs to be spent on a particular public service, and the amounts that can or will be raised through a specific tax.
The Association of Accounting Technicians (AAT) welcomes the announcement of one of the biggest ever cash investments into the UK road network, but cautions against the belief that hypothecation will solve road funding problems.
Given that VED raises less money than needed to cover the costs of developing and maintaining the UK’s roads, and that on current trends it will decline further owing to the switch to electric vehicles, it is reasonable to ask just how significant this hypothecation commitment will be over the next 5 to 10 years in encouraging the introduction of further hypothecated taxes. It could conceivably be just a toe in the water. Based on the success or otherwise of this measure, a wider case could be made for or against hypothecation. As Paul Morton, the Director of the Office of Tax Simplification, suggested in his blog just a few months ago, there needs to be greater public understanding of hypothecation before it is foisted upon them. This could be a helpful start.
There is certainly room for ongoing debate – which is why I look forward to further discussions hosted by Common Vision’s Tax Lab on this subject.