The question of whether the time is right for (more) tax hypothecation is a particularly timely one. Its pertinence leads on from the commitment to increased funding of £20.5 billion per year for the NHS. According to a survey in Deloitte’s recent State of the State report, 62% of citizens support higher public spending, even if it means tax rises. There is a clear temptation to see hypothecated taxes as a “silver bullet”, individuals seem more willing to pay more tax if they value the service being funded and, in theory, hypothecation allows the public to hold governments to their spending promises.
The introduction of a ‘strong’ hypothecated tax would tie extra NHS spending to a single tax revenue. However, it is inevitable that mismatches will arise between the optimal amount that needs to be spent on public services, and the amounts that can or will be raised through a specific tax. Given that tax yields fall in a recession – that is, when spending needs are likely to increase -this approach then would inevitably subject the NHS budget to the unpredictability of economic cycles. Based on actual National Insurance Contribution (NICs) receipts and NHS spending in the years after 2007-8, it would have been necessary to either cut NHS spending or raise NIC rates during the recession under a ‘strongly’ hypothecated model.
Supplementing funding from a hypothecated tax with additional revenue (and/or taking revenues for other purposes in times of surplus) can of course address revenue volatility concerns surrounding hypothecation. Although hypothecation can appear to improve transparency and the accountability of government spending, this type of diluted hypothecation significantly weakens the link between the increased tax revenues and the original intention for which public support was obtained. This dilution is likely to increase over time as revenues and expenditure begin to diverge.
Given the critical issues of public understanding and engagement, we would welcome a succinct and balanced discussion on the future of hypothecation in UK tax policy.
Having said that, a hypothecated tax with a volatile base is unlikely to deliver the type of revenue needed to develop a sustainable funding model for the NHS or other key public services. Leveraging support for the NHS to introduce or extend taxes that are hypothecated in name only risks distrust in our tax system.
Therefore, to the extent that hypothecation is a useful tax policy tool it should be reserved for narrow policy objectives, such as those where it is possible to establish a clear correlation between the tax paid and the benefit received (e.g. building a new toll bridge) or to drive behavioural change (e.g. soft drinks industry levy). We cannot see a convincing case for using it more widely.