At the Conservative conference this week, the Chancellor Phillip Hammond made the announcement that the UK government would look to address the ‘digital tax gap’.
Rather than the conventional definition of ‘tax gap’, which is the difference between the overall tax owed by law and the tax that the government ultimately collects (and according to figures from HMRC, the UK continues has one of the lowest tax gaps in the world), the ‘digital tax gap’ is a term referring to what is increasingly viewed by politicians and the public alike as a failure of the corporate tax system’s to adequately tax the value created by users for big tech companies.
At a fringe event co-hosted by the Chartered Institute of Taxation and the Institute for Fiscal Studies the day after the Chancellors announcement, a panel of tax policy experts welcomed the sense that thus announcement would move the discussion along at a faster pace than the current work being done by the European Union and the OECD. It was also a shared view that the strict opposition of the United States to any changes in the current tax regime affecting digital companies continues to throw a wrench in international efforts, making alternative domestic efforts such as the one announced by the Chancellor understandable.
However, speakers also agreed that there didn’t seem to be a singular right answer, debating the pros and cons of the various types of taxes that could be used to address the issues arising from changing global markets. Paul Johnson, Director of the IFS, stressed that while taxing profits “where the profits are generated” may be a straightforward concept, it is a difficult one to implement. He also made a point of challenging some common fundamental assumptions underlying the current debate surrounding corporate taxation, including emphasising that while 87% of taxes are remitted to government by businesses, corporation taxes are ultimately paid by people – be that company’s shareholders (who may not always be rich individuals), workers or customers.
The concept of a tax on where sales are made rather than where value is created was contested by others. EY’s Claire Hooper argued that the tax system should make sure to weigh up companies’ upfront investments against their subsequent earnings, the conundrum being whether the users are creating the values, or whether the company’s algorithm that generates the collection of their data is actually where the value lies?
Nailing how exactly a company creates the values that should then be taxed caused clashes between the speakers. In regards to a value-added tax on data collection, for example, they pointed to a series of difficult questions which immediately arise: What is a company’s process for collecting the data? How does it store the data? Where are the company’s brick and mortar, headquarters, and management teams located?
Fairness as a concept for tax policymaking can be ‘slippery’, as Paul Johnson from the IFS put it. However, the concept can also lend itself well to ensuring decision makers consider taxpayers as a whole – from the small local bookshop on the high street to the classic example of Amazon, Robert Courts MP pointed out. Business rates were a priority concern for the audience members, who questioned the panel on their plans to fix existing issues surrounding declining footfall for local businesses on the UK high street. When one audience member blamed high business rates, both Financial Secretary to the Treasure Mel Stride MP acknowledged that businesses were struggling but that lowering business rates would not solve the issue, as customers’ consumption patterns have drastically shifted over the last few decades.
Digitalised economies and the challenges facing the traditional high street have shaken up perceptions of what is responsible, appropriate and pragmatic in the tax system. It’s no surprise that these questions were the focus of hot debate this party conference season, but as one short fringe event makes clear, there are plenty of issues which reach within and beyond subjective notions of ‘fairness’ in the public discussion on responsible taxation of multinational corporations, the business world’s continued digital shift, and domestic government’s role and responsibilities in response.