Let’s consider local hypothecation

Hypothecation is an important debate, but should be one that is built upwards – through freedoms and flexibilities on council taxation, or local income taxes, or possibly, local social care taxes. Though little direct research has been done its been anecdotally observed, good participation increases willingness to trust government, and by implication, I would argue, […]
The case for hypothecation in the introduction of new taxes

In the previous article I made the case that hypothecation is misleading in that it reduces public spending to a ‘factory model’ of inputs and outputs, whereas in fact there are many complex factors which achieve social outcomes. However, there is one case where I believe the argument for hypothecation is strong, and that is in the […]
Hypothecation: beyond the ‘factory model’ of taxation

There is an argument that we should oppose hypothecation on the grounds that it is misleading, reducing the economy to a ‘factory model’ of inputs and outputs. The hypothecation of taxation implies that politics works like an factory making many products. This factory model of taxation implies that you get out of the economy what […]
What does “fair” business taxation look like in a digital world?

At the Conservative conference this week, the Chancellor Phillip Hammond made the announcement that the UK government would look to address the ‘digital tax gap’. Rather than the conventional definition of ‘tax gap’, which is the difference between the overall tax owed by law and the tax that the government ultimately collects (and according to […]
Is the time right for (more) tax hypothecation?

The concept of hypothecation, where revenues from specific taxes would be ringfenced for a particular expenditure purpose – and publicly communicated in this way – has become the subject of growing interest and attention from politicians, public bodies and the press. It is increasingly cited as a potential way to address the challenge of funding […]
Exploring tax hypothecation from first principles

The concept of tax hypothecation has become the subject of much recent attention from politicians, the press and the public at large as government wrestles with how best to raise the funds it needs for public finances, while at the same time looking to rebuild the trust of taxpayers. At PwC we think that the […]
For hypothecation to work we need better public understanding of the tax system

A few years ago there was a provincial tax in a large country not far from Europe called “the tax in support of the local football team”. It may be that this was a particularly popular way of raising more revenue although those who were not soccer enthusiasts might have been less impressed. This is, […]
NHS funding: Why the rush to raise new taxes?

Initial reactions to the announcement of a 70th birthday funding boost for the NHS were broadly positive, with Government statements promising an extra £20 billion for the health service by 2023/24. The money will come from the ‘Brexit dividend’, from higher borrowing and from increased taxes. The Prime Minister insists that tax increases will be […]
Hypothecated taxes: Shifting from crisis to prevention

Hypothecated tax – the pre-allocation of a tax for a given cause – is everywhere at the moment. But in discussions of how impractical it is in technical terms, one major factor driving its appeal as a political tool seems to have been overlooked. This is the emotional space it creates, allowing the taxpayer to feel […]
Tax hypothecation raises important questions about public understanding

The Responsible Tax Lab’s recent work on tax hypothecation has raised some very important questions about public awareness of how much tax is raised and how it is spent. For example, many people might take the view that more should be spent on the NHS and on health in general, but few would be able […]