Skip to content
Me
Me

The Responsible Tax Lab

How can business and civil society work together to restore trust in the tax system?

The Responsible Tax Lab

About the project

The Responsible Tax Lab is a long term programme focusing on how businesses and civil society can work together to design and encourage a responsible tax system. The Lab launched in December 2016, drawing on Common Vision’s previous experience of convening people and organisations who want to be proactive and aspirational in developing and providing the practical ideas, tools and resources that would make our future tax system fit-for-purpose.

Tax hypothecation is a growing subject of public and political discussion. While many economists and commentators have previously been sceptical of hypothecated models, there is growing recognition of the need to introduce new accountability mechanisms to assist trust in revenue authorities and tax morale, and with it potential improvements in compliance. We set out to explore the practicalities and implications of hypothecation and whether a hypothecated tax system in the UK could contribute towards higher levels of public trust and clearer accountability of monies raised.

Share this project

Aims and objectives

The concept of hypothecation, where revenues from specific taxes would be ringfenced for a particular expenditure purpose – and publicly communicated in this way – has traditionally been unpopular with many. This is because of the notable challenges, relating to complexity, transparency, and public perceptions, with which it is associated. However, there is acceptance that hypothecation could act as a unifying tool and help engage people on tax, especially in the context of raising additional tax revenues and increasing public trust in the tax system. The time is ripe to explore whether hypothecation models have the potential to define the goals of taxation and explain these to the public.

  • What do we mean when we say ‘hypothecation’ and how many forms can it take?
  • What examples of the uses of hypothecation can be found in the UK and elsewhere in the world, and what can we learn from them?
  • What lessons can be learned from other participatory public spending models?
  • What are the risks of tying public spending on a particular area/service to a single tax revenue?
  • What applications of hypothecation might be suitable for use today?
  • Can a more responsible tax-paying culture be encouraged and enhanced through tax hypothecation?
  • What are the long-term societal and democratic implications of introducing strong forms of hypothecation?
Methodology

This workstream brought together a range of interested stakeholders from government, public bodies, think tanks, civil society and the accounting and tax profession to debate the opportunities and potential for hypothecated taxation models, alongside a review of academic and policy literature.

Partners

This workstream from the Responsible Tax Lab was sponsored by PwC.

“At PwC, our purpose is to build trust in society and solve important problems. Through our Paying for Tomorrow campaign we are committed to contributing to the debate on building a tax regime that is fit for the future. Through this campaign we aim to gather a wide range of views in taking a strategic look at the tax system. As such, we hope that this study will help kick start broader thinking and debate around what type of tax system we need and whether hypothecated taxes have a role to play.” – Stella Amiss, PwC

Loading...

Summary Report

Responsible Tax: New rules for Brexit Britain

A number of possibilities lie in store for the UK’s tax system outside the EU. In the context of Brexit, a political climate in which rapid change is possible, a first-principles discussion of tax policy making is not only necessary, but ever more urgent.

This report argues that Brexit provides the opportunity for a ‘culture shift’ on tax policy. This means looking at what can be done differently to build the foundations of a more constructive dialogue, so that all citizens can have a shared understanding of what we are trying to achieve with our tax system, who is responsible for achieving it and who ultimately bears the cost.

Click here TO READ THE REPORT

Summary Report

Follow the Money

Click here TO READ THE REPORT

Articles and commentary

Latest Insights

Loading...

If I were Chancellor… I’d ensure long-term UK tax policy doesn’t become a casualty of the coronavirus

Loading...

by

George Bull

March 10, 2020
The run-up to the UK Budget on 11 March 2020, the first since 29 October 2018, is the most peculiar I can remember. Under then-Chancellor...
Read More

If I were Chancellor… I’d forget tinkering and focus on the bigger questions

Loading...

by

John Cullinane

March 10, 2020
For a number of years now, the CIOT has been calling for an end to the traditional Budget Day Pantomime. No more ‘rabbits from hats’ – surprise announcements...
Read More

Who spends more wisely: Individuals or government?

Loading...

by

Danny Dorling

January 24, 2019
Will 2019 see an end to austerity? Last year, the Chancellor announced that the ‘era of austerity is finally coming to an end’ nearly four...
Read More

Can hypothecation bring greater transparency to business taxation?

Loading...

by

Stephen Herring

December 13, 2018
No one can deny that tax policy for businesses has a much higher public profile than it did five years ago and the forthcoming changes...
Read More

Hypothecation: An idea whose time has come, or a proxy solution for deeper concerns?

Loading...

by

Ben Thatcher

November 12, 2018
Further to the publication of our report, Follow the money: Is the time right for (more) tax hypothecation in September, Common Vision hosted an event in Parliament...
Read More

Tax devolution: A help or hindrance to the UK’s cities, regions and nations?

Loading...

by

Malina McLennan

November 1, 2018
There has been a recent increase in policy discussions regarding the possibilities of devolved tax policymaking and tax collection in the UK. This has in...
Read More

The 2018 Budget: is hypothecated road tax just a toe in the water?

Loading...

by

Phil Hall

November 1, 2018
The potential use of hypothecated taxation has gained increasing popularity amongst commentators, most notably several think tanks. The UK Treasury supposedly despises the concept. As...
Read More

The NHS, National Insurance, and a case for narrow hypothecation

Loading...

by

Daniel Lyons

October 25, 2018
The question of whether the time is right for (more) tax hypothecation is a particularly timely one. Its pertinence leads on from the commitment to...
Read More

Tax in the evolving world of corporate social responsibility: Copenhagen conference summary

Loading...

by

Malina McLennan

October 12, 2018
Where exactly does responsibility lie for paying taxes, and ensuring taxes are paid? Does it sit with the legal system to set practical and enforceable...
Read More

Let’s consider local hypothecation

Loading...

by

Jez Hall

October 10, 2018
Hypothecation is an important debate, but should be one that is built upwards – through freedoms and flexibilities on council taxation, or local income taxes,...
Read More

The case for hypothecation in the introduction of new taxes

Loading...

by

Danny Dorling

October 6, 2018
In the previous article I made the case that hypothecation is misleading in that it reduces public spending to a ‘factory model’ of inputs and outputs, whereas...
Read More

Hypothecation: beyond the ‘factory model’ of taxation

Loading...

by

Danny Dorling

October 4, 2018
There is an argument that we should oppose hypothecation on the grounds that it is misleading, reducing the economy to a ‘factory model’ of inputs...
Read More

What does “fair” business taxation look like in a digital world?

Loading...

by

Malina McLennan

October 3, 2018
At the Conservative conference this week, the Chancellor Phillip Hammond made the announcement that the UK government would look to address the ‘digital tax gap’....
Read More

Is the time right for (more) tax hypothecation?

Loading...

by

Caroline Macfarland

September 1, 2018
The concept of hypothecation, where revenues from specific taxes would be ringfenced for a particular expenditure purpose – and publicly communicated in this way –...
Read More

Exploring tax hypothecation from first principles

Loading...

by

Stella Amiss

August 31, 2018
The concept of tax hypothecation has become the subject of much recent attention from politicians, the press and the public at large as government wrestles...
Read More

For hypothecation to work we need better public understanding of the tax system

Loading...

by

Paul Morton

August 31, 2018
A few years ago there was a provincial tax in a large country not far from Europe called “the tax in support of the local...
Read More

NHS funding: Why the rush to raise new taxes?

Loading...

by

George Bull

June 19, 2018
Initial reactions to the announcement of a 70th birthday funding boost for the NHS were broadly positive, with Government statements promising an extra £20 billion...
Read More

Hypothecated taxes: Shifting from crisis to prevention

Loading...

by

Abby Gilbert

May 29, 2018
Hypothecated tax – the pre-allocation of a tax for a given cause – is everywhere at the moment. But in discussions of how impractical it is...
Read More

Tax hypothecation raises important questions about public understanding

Loading...

by

Paul Morton

May 18, 2018
The Responsible Tax Lab’s recent work on tax hypothecation has raised some very important questions about public awareness of how much tax is raised and...
Read More

Taxpayer communications – are more engaging alternatives possible?

Loading...

by

Caroline Macfarland

April 18, 2018
How can communications transform the way that taxpayers perceive tax? What role can design and data play in promoting or provoking sentiments towards taxation? How...
Read More

Hypothecation and devolution: Parallel trajectories?

Loading...

by

John Cullinane

April 18, 2018
Hypothecation might simply mean that the Treasury raises a particular tax, promises to spend it on a particular thing, and at the outset does exactly...
Read More

Hypothecation, participation and rebuilding trust

Loading...

by

Jez Hall

April 13, 2018
No one likes paying tax. Increased council tax bills are dropping through our letterbox. Council tax is the biggest individual tax demand most of us...
Read More

A review of the B Team Responsible Tax Principles: Part two

Loading...

by

Caroline Macfarland

March 22, 2018
The B Team, a nonprofit initiative formed by a group of business leaders from around the world, launched a framework for responsible corporate tax practice...
Read More

Tax policy in Brexit Britain: A more strategic approach

Loading...

by

Kate Bell

February 21, 2018
The TUC has long argued that a more strategic approach to the economy is necessary to addressing the challenges we face if we want to...
Read More

Questions for the tax system in Brexit Britain

Loading...

by

Grace Bremner

February 21, 2018
How can we design a responsible tax system in post-Brexit Britain? An interesting question and, at the moment, one which elicits more questions than answers....
Read More

New tax rules for Brexit Britain?

Loading...
February 21, 2018
Brexit represents a conundrum for tax policymakers. On the one hand, leaving Europe provides the opportunity to abandon EU restrictions on the UK tax system, allowing...
Read More

Certainty, simplicity and accountability: A welcome approach

Loading...

by

Phil Hall

February 21, 2018
Today’s Common Vision report, Responsible tax: New rules for Brexit Britain? makes a number of welcome recommendations for tax policy change in the UK.  There are three...
Read More

Can Brexit be used as the focus for a wider debate on tax policy?

Loading...

by

Judith Knott

February 21, 2018
Tax came into the public spotlight following what I would describe as a first ‘wave of populism’, from about 2010. This followed the financial crisis,...
Read More

Brexit: An opportunity to take a brave standpoint on tax fundamentals

Loading...

by

Jonathan Riley

February 20, 2018
Although some may argue that Brexit will mean little time for politicians and civil servants to focus on other national policy issues, there is also...
Read More

Can the tax system help address economic uncertainty in Brexit Britain?

Loading...

by

Allison Roche

February 20, 2018
Exiting the EU and entering a new EU-UK agreement present us with a great opportunity to revisit the UK tax system and ask what we...
Read More

Making the case for a competitive tax system post-Brexit

Loading...

by

Stephen Herring

February 19, 2018
It is clear that the UK government wishes to secure sufficient flexibility post-Brexit – or, perhaps more accurately, post any transitional/implementation period – to address...
Read More

Corporate tax strategies: Building trust or ticking boxes?

Loading...

by

Nick Blundell

February 1, 2018
2017 may now seem a dim and distant memory, but the end of last year saw the requirement for affected companies with a December year...
Read More

Making tax policy post-Brexit: An international perspective

Loading...

by

Judith Knott

January 25, 2018
This week, I took part in a seminar run by the All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Responsible Tax. This was the group’s second session on...
Read More

‘Taking back control’ of the tax debate

Loading...

by

Abby Gilbert

January 24, 2018
A recent event hosted by Common Vision’s Responsible Tax Lab asked whose responsibility is it to bridge the gap between public expectations and understanding of the tax...
Read More

The tax technology revolution: What else do we need apart from tech?

Loading...

by

Max Ostrowski

January 23, 2018
A technology revolution is coming to the world of tax. This was clear from a recent conference co-hosted by Common Vision’s Responsible Tax Lab at...
Read More

Gaming the tax system: A creative approach to engaging citizens

Loading...

by

Timo Laukkanen

January 19, 2018
Research on the attitudes of Finnish citizens towards tax shows that Finns are some of the happiest taxpayers in the world. A survey carried out...
Read More

Digital tax transformation: A new opportunity for developing countries

Loading...

by

Jeffrey Owens

January 17, 2018
Blockchain, fintech, cloud computing, AI, the internet of things (IoT), 3D printing, industry 4.0, among other innovative technologies, have the capacity to transform the operation...
Read More

Making sense of the Paradise Papers: The very bad, the not so bad and the socially useful

Loading...
November 20, 2017
Following the series of stories emerging from the ‘Paradise Papers’ has been like unpacking a Christmas stocking. While each individual item may be underwhelming in...
Read More

Offshore tax: Will the debate ever change?

Loading...

by

Jon Ward

November 15, 2017
Most references to tax in the media of late have been about the “Paradise Papers”, the latest leak of data derived from 13.4 million documents...
Read More

Have personal service companies had their day?

Loading...

by

Bill Dodwell

July 21, 2017
In 1999, Chancellor Gordon Brown announced that measures would be introduced to counter tax avoidance by the use of so-called “personal service companies”. The measures...
Read More
1 2 Next »

Sign up to our newsletter

We believe in using the power of positive ideas to shift the narrative about the future away from toxic, angry debates and towards shared ambition and collaborative action.

Facebook-f Twitter Linkedin Youtube
  • 27 Dingley Place, London. EC1 8BR
  • hello@covi.org.uk

Common Vision UK is a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales. Company Number 08837291.

Copyright 2026 © All rights reserved.

Read our Privacy Policy here.

  • Home
  • About
  • Projects
  • Events
  • Articles
  • People
  • Library
  • Home
  • About
  • Projects
  • Events
  • Articles
  • People
  • Library
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.